We've been on the wrong side of some poor decisions tonight. I hope to fook we get saints in the play offs

Ref is absolute w@nk

Got to agree and think the RFL seriously need to look at the state of current officiating for supposedly professional officials. Mind you when you put an idiot like Ganson in charge what do we all expect?

Can't fault the effort from tonight just a few too many daft/poor decisions.

Saints are not even close to been good enough. Neither are Wigan. Unless things radically change, it's between us and Warrington this year all day long.

Wilkin needs to retire

This ref is pants.

Fantastic turn out from our fans again for a Friday night especially after an expensive weekend last Saturday.

That was poor play to put Michaels into touch.

Not even close to Superleague standard. And that's not saying much as the SL standard is not that high!

Brilliant from Shaul to catch Swift.

Well Saints have won it but Hull have done brilliantly in the circumstances. The ref shouldn't be allowed near the Super 8's again.

What was the point of Downs on the bench?

Game over, great effort, but lacking some class and energy.

Didn't get many 50/50's either.

scoreline flatters saints now. I hope we don't concede again. watts was immense when he was on, green has done well and manu has worked his nads off. Massive efforts from those who played last week

Jesus, how many forward passes!

Shame to lose. But Saints don't look good enough to get to Old Trafford.

Unless they improve massively, they will get humiliated. Our full pack would have decimated them up the centre. And without the ref, they are 12 points poorer today.

saints been really lucky with the fixtures this year. 4 points against us and wire they wouldn't have got if it weren't for the cup games

Im just amazed how Saints have made the 4, shows how poor the rest of the comp is outside the top 8.

great effort lads, well done,

Saints have played a cup finalist the last 3 years.

Don't think any of the fringe players have made a real push to make Radfords 17.

Hmm if we make the Grand Final I wonder if we've just seen the ref the RFL will choose to ref the match

Not too bothered about that, wasn't expecting anything spectacular with so many regulars rested but we still put in a commendable performance. As others have said, full strength we would have slaughtered them.

Naughton probably had a game to forget. Thought Hadley and Feka both came up well.

Abdul is getting better and better with a lot better pre season he could be our 6 next year leave Carlos in centre with griffin proud of the lads efforts tonight lucky saints getting us after the final if its them we play in the semi I would be very confident of victory