Quote ="Tony Soprano"I agree, many coaches hide half backs out wide when defending to keep then fresh and It's a good ploy, I'm just pointing out that size or lack of it does not make you a weakness in defence. A good play maker will always be a target for the forwards.'"
Exactly. Being targeted does not mean you are a weak tackler, it often means you are an influencial attacker.
I read Kevin Walters book a few years ago and he pointed it out then that he was targetted at Brisbane and got some criticism, but they worked on a structure that covered him, not just be putting him out wide, but sometimes putting him in the middle where he was part of a 3 man tackle rather than 1-1. It just depends on what kind of tackler you are.
Long stands on the wing because he is fast enough to catch a winger, but he doesn't stand there when the kick is going in and doesn't often tackle the big forward because someone else gets across to help in the tackle. It takes a very organised defense to switch players round part way through the 6 but that is what the good teams do.
In my opinion, we don't need to replace Obst or Brough and Drew for that matter, but just make sure that targetting them is not effective.