Beat that.

Tomkins - pre 2013 form
Robinson
Connolly
Renouf
Richards
Barrett
Lam
Smith (Craig)
Newton
Cowie
Bateman
Farrell (Andy)
O'loughlin

Pongia
O'Connor
Hoffman
Hock

Id have Carmont instead of a 2000 Connolly and prob look at getting Furner in there also. pretty formidable team. Considering theres no Coley, Finch, Dallas, Hansen, Tommy, Radlinski there speaks volumes.

S. Tomkins
Robinson
Connolly
Renouf
Dallas
Barrett
Lam
Smith (Craig)
Newton
Cowie
Furner
J. Tomkins
Farrell

Pongia
O'Connor
O'Loughlin
Hock

For me Dallas was a far superior winger to Richards. I also thought Furner was excellent for us along with Joel Tomkins at his best.

Tomkins
Robinson Connolly Renouf Richards
Barrett Lam
C Smith Newton A Farrell
Bateman Hock O’Loughlin

O’Connor Cowie Hoffman Leuluai

Joel at his best in 2010 and 2011 is very unlucky not to make it. I also felt Carmont could’ve got a place for his displays over a longer period then Renouf but Renouf was just quality. To not have Radlinski in there seems madness but I just can’t get him in ahead of Tomkins or by shifting Tomkins to replace either halfback.

I think O'loughlin at his best was actually a better all round player than Farrell at his best. I preferred Farrell in his younger years when he was known for his fend and running out wide so i picked him at second row where he played most of his rugby in those days.

Radlinski
Robinson
Carmont
Renouf
Richards
Green
Lam
C Smith
Riddell
Cowie
Furner
Cassidy
Farrell

Pongia
O'Connor
Logan
Hansen

2nd best team. Id love to watch a match between 1st choice team and this one

Radlinski
Dallas
Gleeson
Carmont
Carney
Finch
Tommy
Coley
McIllorum
Fielden
J Tomkins
Hansen
Furner

Flower
Feka
Fletcher
Farrell (Liam)

Thank God you're not coach lol

3rd team

Escare
Charnley
Goulding
Gildart
Manfredi
Green
Johns
Clubb
Riddell
Howard
Cassidy
Bailey
O'Neil

Mossop
SeuSeu
Williams
Naverette

If there was worst team since 2000 then Richie Mathers Karl Pryce, Desi Williams and Liam Botham and the player nicknamed Adrian Lam in drag would win

Who was that guy who Millward signed and he cant play after 6pm?

Worst team

Mathers
Desi Williams
Karl Pryce
David Hodgson
Wes Davies
Willie Peters (C)
Dennis Moron
Francis Stephenson
Mark Smith
Brady Malam
Liam Botham
Tim Jonkers
Player who cant play after 6pm????

Willie Peters wasn't that bad, was he?

No but i cant think of anybody worse after Moron. Ill tell you what, since hes unlucky to be in there he can be captain

Really wanted us to keep him at the time

Thank god your not

No Lauaki in the worst team?

No, he wanted to try his hand in the NRL and he was a failure.

Youve no O'loughlin but youve got Logan. Yeah whatever,

He can be water carrier

I’d have Amos Roberts before Escare. He was incredible up until that injury in 2010.

or Matty Bowen

Peak Hock beats Peak J Tomkins for me.

Hock in his prime was one of the most fearsome back rowers i have ever seen in any era.

Faz to prop just to accommodate SOL alongside Smith

I thought Bowen had his moments, but Amos Roberts was incredible. Albeit only for 6 months.

Harsh on D. Hodgson! I'd have a few there in front of him. Possibly even David Vaealiki for how much of a let down he was, but then again there was that length of the field try against Saints...

I think the second XIII is probably an even more interesting one, given how many shoe-ins are in the best.

Probably wouldn't make too many changes with your teams (maybe swap 2000 Connolly with Carmont) but the competition for the wing spots are frightening.

After Robinson & Richards, you've got Carney, Dallas, Charnley, Roberts, Manfredi and even a fully fit Burgess who don't have much between them. Actually, the fact that basically nobody has said Charnley despite him getting basically a try a game shows how well off we've been for wingers.