No: not ironic in anyway > paradoxical ; However hypocrisy flows through your post from your own rules .

Well maybe it wasn't as bad as I thought when I saw it live.
Not guilty my lord.

What? That could still break the tackler's sternum.

Oh no, Joel is whiter than white

I'll bet you that he is found guilty.

If he's not I'll pay for the next "Ultras" flag and if he is found guilty you have to add a "Dessie tw*tted Iro" flag to the collection.

I LOVE IT! please take the bet rogues...

Yes, that hi-definition photo has cleared the matter right up.

I'll tell you what I'll do.
£20 to the charity of your choice if he found guilty, £20 to the charity of my choice if he is found not guilty.

Awesome!

I think PY's choice should be the Wigan Ultra cause, including that flag.

+1.

seems to me like mr rogues isnt so confident in tomkins getting away with it anymore......

Surprising, that photo taken with a dodgy Nokia of a TV shot was irrefutable in my view.

rogues, just seen it on offiahs awful bit, you're off you're ing rocker if you dont' think thats guilty.


i know your not though.

Just seen it myself.....he'll get 1 game, just in time to return for the game against us.....bring it on

For the record, as someone's mentioned before....how far forward were those 2 passes for Wigan tries. i bet Shobgite Clarke wont mention that, next time he "graces" our screens

"do you know eddie, the number of tries wigan have scored from Dan marino style passes, surpasses that of every other super league team put together."

As I said when I was the game I thought it was worth a ban.
When I saw it in Sky Sports News I thought MAYBE (being optimistic) that wasn't as bad. I then did a freeze frame and as that picture shows the first impact is on the chest.

Lets see if PY wants to put his £20 against mine for charity. (I'm a poor pensioner b.t.w)

Christ I lose both ways as it will be my taxes that you donate.

You may as well send the £20 to the Wire fans doing the walk to Wrexham now: he's as guilty as Peter Sutcliffe.

hahaha

Well are you going to take the bet?
A simple yes or no will suffice.

And if it's a yes please nominate your charity.
And you only get paid if he gets a ban.

His thumbs were pointing backwards

Woah there! The bet was whether he gets found GUILTY or not. That's a big enough risk with Wigan's history with the disciplinary committee to expect a ban as well is pushing the realms of probability a little too far. Just let me know if you're chickening out.

As per my previous post you can send the £20 to the lad who posts on here and is doing a charitry run to Wrexham for our Crusaders game. I don't need to know where you would have wanted me to send my money as that is irrelevant; he is guilty/ugly as sin.

You can send your money to the Mike Gregory fund, but the bet will only stand if he gets a ban or do you think he will be treated like Morley and Carvell?
Is that o.k?

What's wrong McFly.......chicken.

Rogues can dress this up however he wants..Leading with the elbow is pure thuggery it could potentially put a player out for months with a broken jaw...
I believe this should carry a mandatory 6 match ban.....

And yes Carvell should have got that too last season..

thought J tomkins was a bit dirty. remember wire vs wigan last year, late shot on myler

think everybody else missed it