We really need to drop the try no try rule, if that had been here that try would of been given because the ref sent it up as a try.

Someone rang me from work a minute into th4 second half, ive just got off the phone now to see the celebrations,

#nothappy

Rugby at its best.

I thought the Magic Weekend this year was the best in a good while. It reminded me of the 2000s and the early days off summer rugby, when there was a bit of a carnival atmosphere at every game and there were far more fast and exciting tries being scored (even if the defence wasn't always top notch).

More of the same going forward please. If we want wrestling we can watch WWF (if it's still going?).

Staggeringly high standard.

Chris Kendall upsetting gods own super league club and fans, the little scamp.

He'll be reffing Barrow reserves next week.

Good tackle from Welsby. Can't wait for the 45 minute highlight package

Toby King doing what he does best. Shooting out of line and failing to tackle try scorer.

He's also just passing to his winger without drawing his man as usual(even with a defender missing!!). Senior must be livid having him there.

Saw that too.

i thought he was playing for for us on purpose. Turns out hes just .

Giants look like us, most of this year.

Shell shocked and ineffective

Well they will sign our players

Standard of SL really is bobbins, isn't it

I'd day pound for pound (on a night hull fc conceded a million points) this is the worst performance from a team in sl this year.

Why wasn't that a try for will price??

Can you imagine the fume on this forum if we performed that badly against a 12 man Saints side??



Just goes to show that we aren't the only ones who throw in dreadful displays, yet many of our fans have been lauding Watson, while being on the back of Powell... Will be interesting to see if Huddersfield fans question Watson, and his ability to take them to the next level, after that abject show. Fair to say, many on here would be questioning our coach if we had just thrown that performance in?

He dropped the ball??

lomax knocked it out. Price put his hand( well fingers) on the ball on the floor.

Fair enough. To be honest, I'd pretty much lost interest by that stage and my one viewing of the replay looked like a knock on, but I bow to your opinion if it appears otherwise on continued viewing

I turned it off after 15 minutes and watched some NRL instead.

Why are Wigan fans getting so giddy? Any team can nil Hull, its a doddle

Whilst it is, the standard of one of the sides on TV was sensational tonight. We beat Huddersfield 18-0 with 12 players and 7-0 with 11 players. The effort to not concede was brilliant.

If there’s separation from ball to hand then you need to re-gather it IE catch it or at least grip it to get it back under control. At least, that’s what I’ve heard the video ref say numerous times this season. Pryce lost the ball and never got it back under control

yes if he had lost it.
Lomax attacked the ball and knocked it out so play on. If that had happened before the try line it would be either deemed a knock on by saints if went towards Huddersfield line or play on if it went backwards.

Lomax doesn’t touch the ball, he hits Pryces arm.