Ratchford - 6
Lineham - 7
Goodwin - 6
T King - 8
Charnley - 6
Brown - 4
Roberts - 3
Hill - 5
Clark - 8
Cooper - 5
Livett - 4
Hughes - 5
Westwood -7

Philbin - 7
Patton - 6
G King - 7
BMM - 6

Ratchford - 5
Lineham - 7
Goodwin - 5
T King - 7
Charnley - 5
Brown - 4
Roberts - 5
Hill - 5
Clark - 7
Cooper - 5
Livett - 4
Hughes - 6
Westwood -6

Philbin - 7
Patton - 6
G King - 8
BMM - 5

Do you think Hill may be on the decline? As a Wigan fan ive always been a big admirer of Chris Hill and wished he was at Wigan but i cant help thinking he has been on the steady decline for a couple of years. He had a very good World cup but i no longer fear him when Wigan play Warrington like i used to. Is he going the way Fielden did in his later years? Maybe too many big minutes every week at a younger age?

Im surprised Charnley had a poor game. Hes normally a big game player.

Not easy to grade Charnley, he didn't have a good or bad. He was forgotten. On that basis I gave him 5, middle for diddle.

He's currently nowhere near the player he was and completely ineffective against Cats.

Getting a few passes may have helped Charnley, a spectator for long periods when Warrington had the ball. He could have had a near walk-in late on but yet again, the ball went back the other way.