Just something to pass the time...

Spotted similar things on other forums although I think we'll struggle



With your strongest line-up name any player from Super League who you would replace your existing player with

I've got for part experience part future

Wellens ---
Gardner ---
Gidley ---
Gilmour --- Shenton
Meli --- Hall
Pryce ---
Long ---
Graham ---
Cunningham ---
Hargreaves --- Peacock
Puletua ---
Flannery --- Westerman
Wilkin ---

Roby ---
Clough ---
Fa'asavalu ---
Cayless --- Morley

hall for meli...disgrace. meli is a dude.
get sam burgess in the team

Don't believe all the hype. He was a flash in the pan.
A poor man's Hargreaves.

Peacock for Cayless thats it. We're not top for nothing

Burgess looks shot at the moment,,he is starting to remind me of Fielden..

Burgess needs other quality to grow and has to stop doing three man's work over the park just like Graham. Bring him to us and we will see how beneficial the sharing of the work load between Graham and Burgess would be for Saints as a whole.

You've got to remember Burgess is still coming back from his shoulder reconstruction. He's light on weight work and has a lot of improvement in him this season. He'll get better as the season goes on.

And Hall over Meli? What the hell? Is this the Hall that plays for Leeds? He's nothing, solid but not someone we would replace Meli with even if he was free.

sad to say this, but Sam Burgess isn't even the best in his family, never mind Super League.Going back 18 months or so, he looked as though he was gonna be the next big thing, but he doesn't seem to have progressed much. I know he's had his fair share of injuries, but don't most players?

He's still recovering from his Shoulder op. He still can't do much in the gym yet and has to be careful going into tackles for a while yet. Once he's fully 100% you'll change your mind. And to say Luke is better than him is idiotic, plus hes a year or two older.

Rob Burrow

Why change a winning team ? At a push though Burgess and Peacock for Hargreaves and Cayless.

Hall over Meli ?

Giver over!

I wouldn't have Hall over Meli. Maybe Tadulala or Hicks but despite Hall's tries he is yet to prove himself defensively.

sherrife for meli.

Great piece of play in his own in-goal last night.

we could couch those silly little things out of him.

I can't believe nobody has said they would swap Gildey for Carmont.

We could coach them out of Platt too.

Shocking that!