But he wasn't playing prop all last season, so it isn't really a fair comparison when you are a running outside the centre channels is it?

he was for almost all, but i take your point

fozzard has struggled this year, but i accept he is a stop-gap for the year. i expect clough to be used as a prop..



as for is he injured. from the headline on saints website, it would suggest that everyone is fit

Every day of the week

Quote pedro17="pedro17"Every day of the week'" Coley is not even close to Puletua mate, you're losing the plot. It's an absolute massacre: www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 SOL is certainly a better 13 than Roby, but then Roby is a hooker so no surprises there.

Quote pedro17="pedro17"Every day of the week'" Coley is not even close to Puletua mate, you're losing the plot. It's an absolute massacre: www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 SOL is certainly a better 13 than Roby, but then Roby is a hooker so no surprises there.

Quote pedro17="pedro17" Quote pedro17="Saint Simon"Coley and O'loughlin better than Puletua and Roby I'd have J Tomkins over Wilkin on current form though, the others are close calls really and you could argue either way'" Every day of the week'" Roby v O'Loughlin www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 yes they play in different positions, but he is a much better forward, and would be a better 13 if he played there

Quote pedro17="pedro17" Quote pedro17="Saint Simon"Coley and O'loughlin better than Puletua and Roby I'd have J Tomkins over Wilkin on current form though, the others are close calls really and you could argue either way'" Every day of the week'" Roby v O'Loughlin www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 yes they play in different positions, but he is a much better forward, and would be a better 13 if he played there

Stats dont show much as we have had a harder run than you guys upto now. Lets see after this week when we have played Cas and you guys have played Warrington

they're from the whole of last season

, another excuse please

Quote Saint Simon="Saint Simon"Roby v O'Loughlin www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 yes they play in different positions, but he is a much better forward, and would be a better 13 if he played there'" You are saying Roby is a better forward than Lockers?

Quote Saint Simon="Saint Simon"Roby v O'Loughlin www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 yes they play in different positions, but he is a much better forward, and would be a better 13 if he played there'" You are saying Roby is a better forward than Lockers?

Lets not compare anything under the Noble management as it looks bleek no matter which way we look.



check out the 2010 stats

Coley and O'loughlin are better at giving penalties away, I'll give him that one.

thats because Lockers is a 80 minuts player unlike the others so law of averages says he will.

Fixed

fixed...for what, your own argument?

You don't seem to have commented on the Coley v Puletua stats? Still think Coley is better?

the stats for 2010 say he is

6 games













you sir are a comedy genius!

How did a Nick Fozzard thread turn into a Puletua vs Coley debate ?



FWIW Coley is nothing!!

sorry for pointing out current form....we will see come good Friday

Puletua is ten times the player Coley is.



Roby is probably only 9 times the player O Loughlin is

I've tried to take the redvee specs of as much as possible...



Graham > Fielden (goes without saying, Graham is as good as it gets)

Cunningham > Everyone (KC continues to be vital to Saints, Tommy has looked poor so far this season from the Wigan games I've caught on TV)

Puletua > Coley (On their day, TP is far the better player - although his day doesn't come often enough IMO - however Coley is a liability with ball control and discipline so TP gets the nod)

Flannery = Hansen (couldn't call this, I think Flanners gets a rough deal from a lot of Saints speccies as he's a solid, dependable player IMO. I rate Hansen as well, though. Good yards, and pretty much mistake free)

Wilkin = Tomkins (Wilkin is the classier player, but Tomkins seems to be very consistent - hard to seperate IMO)

Roby < O'Loughlin (Ewld Pubes-for-hair has looked a different player this year, whereas Roby still seems to be struggling with the 'former MOS' tag. Also, Robes strength was always as an impact player and we're not using him as such lately so maybe this isn't a fair comparison).

Interchange: Prescott = Hargreaves (both quality, no nonsense workhorses)

Moore > Bailey (never understood the appeal with Bailey, and Moore has some class about him)

Fa'as > Paleasina (no contest on these season's form)

Clough > Mossop (close call)



Back on thread though, I'd have Fozz in like a shot if he's fit.

I'd take the pies in both these positions.

Oo-er missus.

Puletua played prop the last 3yrs in the NRL. IMO his best postion is prop.