What's to disagree with? Just that I don't think T Mak collided with him. That was it! On Sky Fulltime last night they slowed the incident down and highlighted it and zoomed in, and it still didn't look like anyone collided with Walsh, just that he fell over his own feet. The injury itself looked hideous.

I'm not watching it.


Dislocating my own knee was bad enough, don't need to be watching video nasties to keep me up at night,

You need stronger glasses and open your ears as Bill says Makinson collides with Walsh , i watched fulltime also?

We'll agree to disagree then final word from me



Get well soon Walshy

What happened to Kev Brown in the game? He seemed to be KO'd at one point in the first half and a couple of their fans on the way out were raging about it, saying it was a clear red card.

It's on the BBC that he's been cleared to play next week despite suffering whiplash.

Betts has come out and said Soliola pushed him causing him whiplash? He's not happy?

No shoulder charge, but a push with his hands, causing him to collide with another Widnes player.
"Not Dirty" says BEtts, but was surprised he didn't get a warning for it.

Cummings mentioned something about Sia pushing his body one way but his studs stayed planted putting stress on his knee, think he mentioned it was an unfortunate incident with no malice to injure.

LUKE WALSH UPDATE:

Saints have just tweeted this:
St.Helens R.F.C. @Saints1890 ·
@Saints1890: Brown says Walsh snapped his fibula and will be out for four to five months. "It's happened and now we have to pull together."

Looks a hell of a lot better than we all feared, then.

Back on his feet in the new year, then.

Great news - for him and for us. Should be fit to play next season.

But wer

A terrible injury, but I think this result is the best that could have been hoped for. Back on his feet within 5 months, means he will play again for you Guys next year.

Fibula is the small bone in your leg so not as bad as first feared?

I was expecting to hear his foot came off or something?

Would it be wrong to want to see his x-ray

(just to be nosey)

Better news than expected so send him home and let that winter sunshine get him ready for next season.

We move on.

No. The fibula is the thinner of the two bones running from your knee to your ankle. The fibula is part of the ankle mechanism. Sounds like he snapped it right at the base so the ankle fell out of place. He had a compound fracture as well, the bone coming through the skin.

[url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/28503576?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitterMore of what Brown says is quoted here[/url and it sounds like the timescale for return is more on the optimistic side. So let's hope his recovery goes well!

You'll also notice in that article that Brown is thinking of running with Wheeler and Turner in the halves.

It's certainly better news than I expected it to be, but still a long road or recovery and rehab for Walshy. Good luck to him and I hope it all goes to plan.

I was fearing the worse in that it could have been a career ending injury so thats good news, another positive is that the Walsh family will have absorbed all the respect from most of super league to wish him well to recovery. This might mean he will definitely be in a Saints shirt next season.

I also agree with Browns thinking, Wheeler and Turner is a much better option than Wheeler and Wello. this will probably mean Wello going in the back row replacing Wilkin and having a role of middle defender linking up with the halves.

Better news for the lad. Hope he's back sooner rather than later. Top player.

4 to 5 months? I'd take that every time considering some have been saying it could be 12 months on the sidelines for what was such a freak injury.

At least it's turned out Luke only broke the fibula rather than the tibula as well as can happen in those situations, that would have been a serious length of time out of the game.

Good news about Walsh, hopefully, with a return date due in the off season, there's no need to rush and take any sort of risk.

As for next week, if wheeler and turner are in the halves I'd guess were going with:

McDonnell
Makinson Percival Jones Swift
Turner Wheeler
Amor Roby Walmsley
Soliola Manu
Wellens

Thompson Laffranchi Masoe LMS

With Flanaghan and Dawson being the others named in the 19 man squad. Given the personnel out, that's still a relatively strong squad if someone can find a kicking game...

I don't think he will move Wellens from 1 unless he is going to play in the halves. I think we have enough forwards without having to put Wellens there. Wilkin didn't play last week and he didn't use Wellens there so i don't see why he would do it this week.

I may be wrong but I can't see McDonnell playing this week unless he goes with a back off the bench as a different option.

You're right about it still looking like a fairly strong 17, despite the absence of 4 key players.

Quote ="The Yellow Giraffe"I don't think he will move Wellens from 1 unless he is going to play in the halves. I think we have enough forwards without having to put Wellens there. Wilkin didn't play last week and he didn't use Wellens there so i don't see why he would do it this week. I may be wrong but I can't see McDonnell playing this week unless he goes with a back off the bench as a different option. You're right about it still looking like a fairly strong 17, despite the absence of 4 key players.'" www.totalrl.com/shannon-mcdonnel ... ints-debut Wello in the halfs this week with Shannon making his debut

Quote ="The Yellow Giraffe"I don't think he will move Wellens from 1 unless he is going to play in the halves. I think we have enough forwards without having to put Wellens there. Wilkin didn't play last week and he didn't use Wellens there so i don't see why he would do it this week. I may be wrong but I can't see McDonnell playing this week unless he goes with a back off the bench as a different option. You're right about it still looking like a fairly strong 17, despite the absence of 4 key players.'" www.totalrl.com/shannon-mcdonnel ... ints-debut Wello in the halfs this week with Shannon making his debut

And yet elsewhere Brown says he's playing Wheeler and Turner in the halves!

Never take what Brown says too seriously ...

Quote ="Rommel"www.totalrl.com/shannon-mcdonnell-set-make-saints-debut/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=shannon-mcdonnell-set-make-saints-debut Wello in the halfs this week with Shannon making his debut'" Those comments were made by Brown last Friday night. These were made yesterday: www1.skysports.com/rugby-league/ ... broken-leg

Quote ="Rommel"www.totalrl.com/shannon-mcdonnell-set-make-saints-debut/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=shannon-mcdonnell-set-make-saints-debut Wello in the halfs this week with Shannon making his debut'" Those comments were made by Brown last Friday night. These were made yesterday: www1.skysports.com/rugby-league/ ... broken-leg