That is one of the craziest things I have ever read on here, and there has been some crazy posted on here.

All three of them are nowhere near the natural talent of Sculthorpe, come on now.

I would like to see Roby given a go there on a more permanent basis to see how he goes, but it would probably mean that we need a bigger back row to compensate with Wilkin/Flannery coming out of the starting line up. My biggest gripe with Flannery is that he simply won't risk a pass to his centre despite creating one-on-ones on a regular basis, and when he has one of the best in Super League on his outside it is such a waste (see the Grand Final for some perfect examples). Wilkin puts the work in and whilst I don't think he as effective offensively as he once was, I still think he offers a lot to the team through his attacking lines and defense.

If we went with Roby at loose, my first choice pack would probably be:

Graham
Moore
Fozzard
Soliola
Wilkin
Roby

Faasavalu
Puletua
Cunningham
Flannery (although I would probably go with another prop or Clough, you can't leave out a high earner who takes a quota spot. Try justifying that to the shareholders!)

It's certainly food for thought anyway.

I would go for a starting pack of:-

8 Graham
9 Cunningham
10 Fozzard
11 Puletua
12 Soliola
13 Roby

Just imagine Eastmonds and Pryce's capabilities playing behind that lot.

There's nothing wrong with him being our versatile player. We need players like that and he never lets us down when he shifts position. His defence and workrate are excellent yet he doesn't really have the skills to make a half back and is a bit small for loose forward. He could definitely help us out at centre and I'd like to see him retain that versatile role because he's very good at it.

I'd be alright behind that lot!