are those stats just when colburn played wing or are they when he played 2nd row and centre as well?

What do you think???

well i dont believe you'd put misleading stats so only when he played winger.

Hmmm.............

Colbons versatility alone makes him much better IMO. Plus Balsawood is a complete nob

Came from the horses mouth when in Australia. I didn't ask Nobby but a couple of my friends did and Nobby told them the truth, IL wouldn't give Liam the money he wanted which still wasn't much compared to other players at Wigan and KR gave him a good offer he couldn't refuse. I understand that Huddersfield, Quins and Salford shown some interest aswell.

But anyway, you have a good player in Liam and hope he continues to do well for you. Apart from when you play Wigan of course

Because ade gardner plays 4 saints and the post was comparing the wingers WIGAN let go

Of the 2 wingers Wigan released, there is no doubt in my mind we got the better deal. I never thought he would let us down as the kid looked pretty solid in the games I watched him play in last season.
Not really put a foot a wrong in the games he has featured in this season and finished off a superb try which looked like it needed alot of work to get it over the line.

Chairman telling the coach who to buy and sell



Happens though, thank goodness Kath pulled out the Dobson deal...always believed she would make a good coach

It's happened with our hooker aswell, even though I'm happy with Piggy Nobby originally wanted to go for Michael Ennis but was wanting alot more than Piggy.

As for Dobbo, can we swap him with Smith please? Tomkins and Dobson as half backs would be nice

Get your filthy cherry and white paws off our Dobbo!!!

Sheldon, I'm still waiting for you to prove that Balsawood is a better signing than Colbon?

He was impressive against Celtic.
The kit lady was very happy that his shirt was still so clean after the game.

that wasn't my point though, as you know, the point was you started a thread about colbon and for no apparent reason you felt the need to bring up one of hull fc's players.

the same as enlightened has just done bringing up our board.

why not discuss your player?

We didn't need versatility, we needed an out and out winger which is what Calderwood is.

no we need more players who can cover 2nd row!

Are you Gareth Raynor

Did you say out on the wing?

Since when were specialist wingers needed at Hull, with your centres you need superman on the wing!!!!! I'm pretty sure Rovers fans are happy with Colbon, highly rated by Noble BTW, and it seem Hull fans are happy with Balsawood, totally unrated by Noble and i might add by 99% of Hull fans prior to his signing.

This is a forum for debate about all things rugby league is it not? I've asked you to provide evidence of something, and you're still unable to offer it.




And I didn't start the thread either.

its not a thread discussing colbon v calderwood though its a thread discussing colbon which means your comment about calderwood is irrelevant.

the thread started off well before your comment about calderwood.

It is now.

I like Colbon, a good finisher, has the size and power to take a tackler or 2 over the line with him...

And Calderwood.......?

Im not really bothered about that Scotsman