I like listening to kirk Dixon,but oh my god gwilum Lloyd,pathetic.

Nothing ever changes how he is still and was ever employed by the bbc is a mystery that even Mulder & Scully wouldn’t be able to work out.

He is so inept at his job, the coaches literally cringe at his questioning.

Your right EY, Gollum is a terrible commentator, and that sing laugh infuriates. Glad I don’t have to listen to this dross every week, bring back Craig Murdock.

thank god I’m not the only one who thinks this way.now that I Carnot get down to the games,I rely on listening on my laptop,and the commentary is usualy good.i must say ,Kirk Dixon makes me laugh with some of his comments,for instance ,he got one right in the mush or he’s got his big paw wrapped round the ball.

If you are on a laptop have you tried to listen via hull fc live? Its biased but no one should be subjected to Gollum Lloyd, he is atrocious. Alternatively when I used to live away from Hull I would try to find the away commentary on BBC Merseyside. BBC Leeds etc, whenever he was on.

Richard Stead and Kirk Dixon are good though.

cheers Steve,will try that in future,always enjoy the banter between Kirk and Richard.gollum should stick to doing rovers games.

I don't think Gwilym is not too bad, he taught Seb all he knows

He’s very much Marmite and I hate the stuff. I remember when Burns was the chief editor, or whatever, at Humberside and he couldn’t stand the man. What began as banter became condescension, he would bollock Gwillam for breathing. Silly sod would have his mike to close to his nose and you could hear it like a steam train. Then there was the time he was commentator on a Catalan’s home game, there was a minutes silence but the daft bugger talked all the way through and he couldn’t understand why everyone was glaring at him until someone told him. Gwillam had a break down and became poorly, that’s why he disappeared for a time and Burns lost the chief oppo’s position and he got the day job.

That explains a lot!!

Has Gwilym still on his committee in the Vicar of Dibley no NO no ,yes?

I thought he’d been sidelined and just did the studio stuff it was cringe having the other commentators trying to drag him back after he went on one of his tangents

It defies belief that he still has a job. He must have a compromising photo of his boss.

Anyone hear the commentary of the last few minutes of the Tour de Yorkshire yesterday evening on RH. GL introduced this guy who went on and on about how exiting the finish was, oh, there's been a crash but the leaders aren't involved, what a fantastic finish, a really tremendous finish....(my words), you get the drift. And then it ended, GL thanked him and that was it.
No mention of who won, no details whatsoever.

Well today we had Brayden Grace, Ryan Grace, Loclan Klute, and Jimmy Klienhorse.
I’m warming to Gwills commentary now, it’s so funny, Pinko “apologies for interrupting you Gwil but a rovers fan has thrown a bottle on, he wants his picture putting in the HDM”

Gwil appears to blow a raspberry on air, as he grabs Schoey and asks which coach should replace Tim, Radders would be good ere, replies Schoey, deathly silence on the radio for a second. You will get me shot said Gwil. If only.........

Bottles being thrown on? Was this today?

Yes after a Saints try.

Wow. Still, if there are no consequences/sanctions by either the club or the RFL it will only continue.

Probably all started by Hull fans ....

It was the best and most efficient example of fans self policing their own stand that I have ever seen. The idiot was identified and ejected within 30 seconds. Hopefully his pass was confiscated and his details taken and a life ban imposed.

Should also point out that given he was wearing a flat cap he was probably a Featherstone fan.

Makinson didn’t really help the situation goading the fans twice after he scored his tries especially when you compare him to Walmsley who came over and clapped the fans

You hear this often but it's impossible to sanction. How can you ban someone for attending games?

I’ve thought that I know football fans that were banned from all grounds had to report to a police station at 3 obviously that wouldn’t work now

Christ! By that flawless logic, I'm also probably a Featherstone fan!

Puts a new slant on 1983 for you then.