Apparently signing for Hull Fc..Thoughts

Can't see it at all, but bloody hope not. Very poor player imo.

He couldn't get in our team in the SR he's got no chance of getting in yours

www.hullfc.com/news/2017-01-28-l ... th-hull-fc

www.hullfc.com/news/2017-01-28-l ... th-hull-fc

The club let Lee Smith train and play for us last year despite them knowing full well we couldn't sign him due to us being at full cap...
we also know Motu Tony has form about telling porkies regarding such and was caught out with his statement to the HDM saying we had cap space for him when we didn't, so glad to see he's learnt a lesson about spouting lies for the sake of PR BS

A lying Tony? I guess we all know one of those.

Motu has said we are not interested in signing him.He is only training with the club to help him keep his fitness whilst looking for a new club

bit of a non story really

We offered Lee Smith a contract, although a low one, we were going to loan out a couple of young kids to make space (I know as I know one of the players Dads, that was going out on loan), he was ready to sign but got a better offer from Leigh.

So only one person speaking BS and it wasn't Motu.

As motu says no chance of him signing for us but rovers really shafted him after their relegation
And he's struggling to get fit for another club so we are helping him out just doing the honourable thing. Bit of a none story as had been said

Exactly how did Rovers shaft him?

... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html

... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html

Quote ="ccs"... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html'" yes but dobbins' prefer to believe saint hudgell, who got them relegated!

Quote ="ccs"... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html'" yes but dobbins' prefer to believe saint hudgell, who got them relegated!

Quote ="ccs"... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html'" Oh dear, very shabby, that. Rovers "declined to comment" on this yet jumped on those seeking a future elsewhere as "running for the hills". Hull Kingston Hypocrites.

Quote ="ccs"... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html'" Oh dear, very shabby, that. Rovers "declined to comment" on this yet jumped on those seeking a future elsewhere as "running for the hills". Hull Kingston Hypocrites.

Quote ="ccs"... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html'" Must be true then.

Quote ="ccs"... well Larroyer seemed to think so. www.hulldailymail.co.uk/rugby-le ... story.html'" Must be true then.

They're not hypocrites, they just deal in "alternative facts"
All swallowed up by the Rervers faithful.

Remember when Hudgell kicked off that SL reduction to 12 wasn't enough and that it should have been 10 to give each SL club more income? Wonder if he stands by that principle right now? Pull up the drawbridge lads.

And Peacocks brainwave to cut funding for lower league teams and redirect it to the games elite.
I wasn't a fan of that idea at the time, but I've since warmed to the idea.

Hull KR. All class.

Indeed.

Whinges to the press about Walker's 'loyalty' because he left to play SL, yet screws over Larroyer because he's deemed surplus to requirements. Loyalty only goes one way it seems.

Thornley, Green, Mantellato, Allgood - no question of their loyalty it seems.

It's not like we should be surprised, from a man of questionable moral standing.

It's not like we should be surprised, from a man of questionable moral standing.

Quite an accusation, could you please explain precisely what you meant by this?
I suggest you look up the laws on slander and defamation before your considered reply.

Didn't he pay a £30,000 fee to hire a man who'd been convicted of kicking another man 27 times in the head whilst said victim was lying on the floor? Some could argue that's questionable moralswise. Just saying. Is it "moral" to use your mobile at the wheel or be responsible for inadequate stewarding? Questions, questions.

Personally I am not a fan of BC, although he does seem to have grown up quite a bit but never having met him I don't feel inclined to judge ( not that I am accusing anybody of judging) Now BC had served in a war zone and who knows the effect that this had on his behaviour, again not condoning but simply arguing that there are sometimes factors that can contribute to stupidity.

If we are talking about criminal behaviour we could look at Stuart Reardon, Leon Price or even Ifeta Paleaaesina. All former Hull players signed after convictions for assault, including on a woman! Perhaps as questionable morally. Although I did not see a rush from Hull FC to get rid of Paul Cooke after his difficulties.

We all have our moral compass but somehow the rivalry does tend to skew it a little.

Oh dear. The points were as follows. Someone questioned Hudgell's morals. You invoked slander and defamation. I pointed out that Neil Hudgell paid a fee, rumoured to be £30k, to acquire Ben Cockayne from Wakefield after conviction for violent crime (and some untoward comments on Twitter) and that this could construed as lacking in robust morality. No one is claiming Hull FC have the highground so your points are an irrelevance to the point made.

Don't forget that crookes kid that punched a women in the face in town

Before anybody thinks I am having a pop, I would like to make clear that I am not, if everybody who made a mistake was not allowed a second chance we would all be in trouble. What I am trying to say is that some people have an irrational dislike of our chairman and are willing to overlook certain facts to support their own view on events. It is easy to have a pop at NH but if you look at his charity he has put a lot back into the city outside of rugby. Perhaps this should be taken into consideration when judging.