Did go down tunnel with physio during warm-up so could be carrying a knock

sounded like he had more rust than the tin man in the wizard of OZ

Both times the ball was knocked out of his hand so his mistake was not securing the ball to ensure we retained possession. Other than that I thought he had a decent game.

Could we have won if he hadnt been playing....i doubt it...other players made errors so did they cost us the game????

Looked a bit knackered at the end, but I am sure he will come better with match fitness.

His errors were due to fatigue/freezing conditions more than anything else.

bemused by the number of fans yelling 'run straight' at each of his kick returns though, he is never going to be a 'crash and barge' Shaun Briscoe type full-back...his strengths are in attack.

broke through the line twice only to be brought back by Ganson , a forward pass and a knock on i believe

Thought he did well tbh and looked a lot better than Phelps. Yes he made a couple of mistakes but it was 0 degrees out there

Was screaming at Ganson for one of them saying it was ripped out. McKinnon looks good, and I've been impressed with him every game so far this year. Always supporting the attack waiting for the offload. Hopefully he'll keep it up.

He was knackered for the last 10, good game otherwise

Well personally I thought he was very good again. Made a couple of errors (although one looked like it was stolen) but that shouldnt detract from the good things he did, safe as houses under the kicks and was everywhere when we had the ball.

thought wade was poor in his ball return and made a couple of unforced errors but he was robbed of a match winning try near the end there is no way that pass which went to ground was forward it was patted backward and was a great pick up by wade ,should have clinched the game for us .

the error which really got under my skin was the westerman knock on before half time really cost us that and was school boy to say the least i was very dissapointed in him ,but over all very good display by the lads shame we couldnt hang on but with out a few players was a great display

we done horne thought him and houghton where outstanding and the young lad danny nic did himself a power of good looked like he could step up to that level big rap for him

Hull fell asleep for the Westerman knock-on and subsequent Warrington try before half-time, which is something we have to cut out of our game. Top sides don't let you have a 5-10mins 'tea-break'

it'll be a different McKinnon next week in the French sun

not the best game today but still someone who'll be a big player this season

Thought McKinnon did well tbh. The Warrington kick chase put him under enormous pressure and they were intent on dislodging the ball every time they went at him. It was a very physical game today and mistakes were bound to be made by all.

Not sure it will be that much warmer in France, forecast for Thursday is high of 5, low of -3, so hardly any warmer than here.

he had a decent game, couple of loose carries but when weather warms up he will be better in this area. some excellent takes of the football today. like others i thought the second of his breaks was legit - looked like the ball had been patted back and down and he picked up on the burst, was unlucky. if anything cost us a win it was the two soft tries in the first half - it wouldn't be fc without at least making one complete hash of a kick off. cut down on silly unforced errors and we will be a good side this year

He was definatley injured. Went off early in the warm up and the physio was on the pitch to him every opportunity he could get.

thought he played well everyone will make errors during a game some people look for someone to be a scapegoat , even on the radio on way home some muppet still saying sharp he,s a liability its cringeworthy some clowns that ring in . all the team deserve a rap great perfomance and will get better if we play like that i will be happy for the season

Thought he did ok seemed to be carrying an injury of some sort both times he dropped the ball it was knocked out by a wire player. Hope he keeps improving and forms a good partnership with out halves.

Thought Wade was OK today, not a stand out but far from liability.

Same here. I thought he was pretty solid today. Looking a good signing for us.

Passed a fitness test beforehand i heard?

Said within ten minutes of kick off he was not the same player we'd seen in the friendlies. Obviously injured. Did not much wrong, but didn't make things happen like he has been.

Hope it's a short term knock. Imagine it is or he wouldn't have been allowed to play at all.

Mckinnon looks dangerous going forward, but seemed to just amble about after a few of their kicks today.

A shocking pass to lynch on our line gave Wire thier first try, but I would question why he is at the ptb. He also coughed up possesion twice.

I won't judge him on one performance, but I hope he was far from his best today.

Agreed. A couple of sloppy moments rather than rustiness IMO. Produced 2 or 3 excellent takes under towering kicks that swirled about plenty as well.