Tonight's positives

- Luaki didn't knock on

- Will Sharp, when he came on, played very well, for me the only player to give a damn! I reckon under the new coach next season, maybe Sharp can make it! (I hope) because he has pace that we need!

- Agar, and the coaching staff are finally fecking off, could they please take Luaki and Washbrook with them.

- We scored two tries

Tonight's Negatives

- Clueless, no heart, no desire, no excuse.

- Agar once again shows he is a clueless coach, god knows what he says to the team before the start of a big game, he just cannot get the team fired up.

- Leeds did not even play that well tonight, we made them look good, and they made us look !


Players that need replacing IF we want to start seriously talking about challenging for honors next season.

- Washbrook (OUT)
- Dowes (OUT)
- Luaki (OUT)
- Horne (OUT)
- Phelps (OUT)
- Whiting (OUT)
- OBST (OUT)
- RADFORD (OUT)

The above players need replacing with some quality, out of the above players, I would maybe keep whiting & obst as backup. Whiting for me, lacks too much in the way of pace, and the past good 4-5 games, he's been caught out to many times, a top quality side, has no weakness on their flanks.

As for sharp, I would give him another season under a new coach, just to see what happens, he has the speed, the attitude, and defense (as shown tonight) to make it work for him.

As for Radford, he's brought nothing to Hull F.C over the past few seasons, he never busts a tackle, gives away daft penalties, and before some of you shoot me and say "but he's there for his leadership" bullshizen! where has it been over the past couple of seasons?

Anyhow. Going to be a very depressing close season now, the only thing that will give me hope for next season is the quick or slow departure of the above named players, with new players coming in!

A depressing season, we did not even deserve to make the play-offs, both us and HKR. We was both in there to make the numbers, the most upsetting thing over-all is Hull RUGBY on a whole, has become a laughing stock, and teams love playing us. In the past people use to hate playing against us, now the big teams think, easy 2 points!

That's all I have to say really, to cap off a very disappointing season

Whiting isn't a winger. HTH.

Well said, and I agree with the "players out" list. Time for realism, not sentiment.

Whiting

I disagree about Whiting, he should stay for me. He ISN'T a winger, but it isn't his fault he has been put out on the wing. I'd agree with the rest. For me, the last 2 games who proven why Phelps isn't good enough for a top team. Against the lower placed teams he looks good against Leeds, Warrington, when you need a game break... annoymous.

Horne was really poor tonight. I wouldn't mind him playing alongside an organising 7 next season and see how he goes, bring in Ellis if Horne isn't good enough. If he did go though, I wouldn't be bothered.

Yes there is far better players than Whiting, I would have him as backup though to slot in during injuries, does people want to challange? or was just getting rid of agar the only thing people wanted? We got rid of Agar, now let's get some good players, we have the money!

If we sign lynch this week, get rid of radford right away!

Amazing, isn't it? I don't know what he has to do to get credit from some people. Of course he shouldn't be a first choice winger, but he's still an integral part of the squad. The idiot who started this thread was bagging him earlier for rarely scoring from his 'countless' interceptions.

Make your mind you here you either want rid or you don't...

Name me a better utility player in SL than Whiting!

Idiot? lol, maybe ambitious yes. I like whiting, hes played well many times, but think about it, under the new coach, wanting to build, where is whiting going to slot in??? Surely cannot be wing can it? And we have adequate cover in the loose forward position.

Think before you post.

Thankfully the faithful are a lot brighter than some on here, the faithful voted him as their player of the year as they clearly see his contribution..
Honestly it really is madness, I guarantee before the season starts we will have a thread saying get rid of him

Sam Tomkins

I will ask you again


Name me a better utility player in SL than Whiting!

He is a full back

Idiot, yes. Whiting can play just about any position to a good or very good standard. Players like that are invaluable in a salary capped sport. Only an idiot would suggest getting rid of him.

Kevin Sinfield.

Whiting out? He is no winger, but I far from want him out of the club.

Sharp was brilliant tonight.

and we will need at least one utility player and for me that should be whiting.

Are you piissed ?

He is a loose man, he would also cost a fortune compared to what we pay Whiting.

Do some people read? I said out of the two, i would have obst and whiting as backup.

I for one don't see a place for whiting next season unless their is injuries, I reckon they will be adequate players in their "CORRECT" positions from the new coach next season!

Whiting should be kept on imo, He's a good squad player and someone "Any team " should have . If Pearson's takeover could have happened a little earlier , I don't think Horne would be here next season either but we've got to play with the cards we have been dealt with for next year.
The rest, I and probably many among us wouldn't disagree .

Who has played 5/8 and on the Wing

Idiot.

I don't want utility though.

Kevin Sinfield is a utility player! Whiting has played out wide all season, does that make him a winger? no you said he's a utility player! where is whiting more effective? in the position HE HAS CURRENTLY NOT BEING PLAYED IN.

Kevin Sinfield is a UTILITY player, but his best position is a loose man

Granted, but we would have to get rid of most of the team to pay his wage