Have we played any game, doesn't have to be consecutive, with the same 17 players this season?

London (away) & Catalan

Mathers
Fox
Sykes
Lyne
Riley
Sammut
Godinet
Scrutton
McShane
Tautai
Ali
Kirmo
Washy

Wilde
Ryan
Molloy
D. Smith

Both games won and then we "experimented" at KR

Nope. Collis & Anderson played against London instead of Washbrook & Molloy.

Not hard to see why we look so unorganised then

Sadly I think the lack of organisation or even ideas goes deeper than that. There is no structure to the team, that's why they look clueless with ball in hand and on particularly on last tackle plays.

Let's give our new coach a chance to make a difference...

Unfortunately he doesn't think anything needs to change.

We've used 8 players in the centre's not including those who have stepped in during games due to injuries! That's an awful lot

appart from dropping are most creative attacking player of the season

Here we go again, Webster isn't dropping Sammut for the laugh of it - he wants to win just as we do. Give the man a chance...

Well if he'd bent is back when we played Bradford it may been different, but he didn't.

To be fair you could level that at most of the players this, and the last two, seasons. Although willing him to do well, Webster's comments in the media are worrying. His team selections don't fill me with confidence either. Hopefully he grows into the role and becomes his own man rather than a clone of Agar.

name 1 player who played well that game and name 1 player who as been better then sammut over the season.

Danny Kirmond.

IMO kirmond hasn't been great this year at all and if we had had depth should have been dropped for a couple of games. I'd say McShane has probably been our most consistent player this season

Almost all of them. To me your seeing what you expected to see from Sammut, the reality is that he has been a dreadful signing so far IMHO and I'd ship him off tomorrow.

Him and Scruton don't want to be here and if you ask me they both expected to have rejoined Bradford by now - wonder why

Webster has gone with what worked for us in the past.
Sammut probably still has a part to play but at least he's not trying to shoehorn him in at the expense of playing another player out of position.
He has brought Smith in an Siejka out and got a win, so it's not a bad start for me.
By the sounds of it Webster May as we'll walk away with a 100% Super League coaching record!

he as been played out off position most of season so no he as not been as good as expected but he still was are only creative player before smith came back

Out of position? The lad played fullback over in AUS before coming over here.

still not were he wanted to be playing for us is it.and not were is creativity would be most useful

Agar didnt rate him and by the looks of it Webster doesnt neither

Sammut is our joint highest try scorer this season, is (only just) our 2nd highest meter maker behind Dan Smith, has made the most tackle busts by far and just one less clean break than our leader in that department, Godinet. He's also kicked 40 out of 49 goal attempts. He has missed less tackles that lumarnaries such as Kirmond & McShane and has more try assists than anyone else in the squad. The only downside he has is his handling errors, but that has always been an issue in his game not just this year, it goes with the way he plays.

He has been our most potent attacking weapon to the naked eye and the stats back it up. We must be going well if we can be leaving him out through choice.

Depends on what you class as a "missed tackle" if you manage to get nowhere near it does that count.

He is creative no doubt but i'm backing the coach on this one for having the guts to drop him.

Dunno but it seems to work for Mathers and he gets picked every week.

A coach will live and die by his decisions. I hope for all our sakes he gets them right.

Come on he's the FB hence they are cheap yards and I suspect you know that - stats are poor indicators for certain things. He hasn't done it for me though I concede he looks better in the halves, I'm still not unhappy at him being dropped or leaving tbh,