Why have we rushed him back. Worsed debut I have seen he looks shot. Knee bandaged up kicking and passing atrocious all game. At 30 he aint going to improve. FOR SALE even after one game !

What a pathetic post.

Why have you rushed him? Because you dont have a squad.

Sell him after one game? Get real.


Hows about realise, That he may need time, To adjust. I am sure he is used to working with better than he is with you, And it will take him time to learn what the players qualities are.

Hes Garbage !

utter garbage! I knew just like salford what he was going to do 10mins b4 he did it, brought nothing to the table, not good enought i'm afraid

Call yourself a supporter of the club and the team, another bagging post from you for a bloke who probably had to play in a key position.

Be happy if you supported someone else to go and bag players.

The team today tried but there was no creativity a bunch of young lads with experience around them, this is a team ti=o grow not berate after every defeat.

I suppose you look in the mirror for reflection perfection.

Ladies and gentlemen we have our scapegoat.

I don't think we could give him away after that performance never mind sell him.

sorry mate but to be on the same wave length as our learned friend you need to remove your brain replace it with a fleas fart have a fetish for eating KFC in medium sized M&S suits and then fail the ***t for brains city n guilds at TEC .

Smith was poor though and Lee was worse. Lees distribution was woeful.

So negative it's untrue. It's his first game, get behind him, not slagging him off straight away!

newgroundb4cas you must be the most fickle fan ever!! I bet you had a similar post saved on your computer that read something like:

"What a debut for Smith, glad John Kear had the bottle to throw him straight in with one leg . . . to the rest of super league hands off the mesiah . . . etc etc"

Your fans, board, coach and players are doing their best to stay positive and pull together. Shame on you!!

I wasn't there, Maybe i cant comment.

But, I remember the Cas fans, In Rangi Chase's first game. He was utter garbage. And look at him now.

Adrian Vowles in his first few games, Was getting similar comments, He went on to be Man of Steel. Sometimes, A player takes time to settle in at a club

Bag players i recall its just about 1 player you dumbo !

look mate if your going talk sense , do one this as the OP suggests is a numpty thread

edited by the all new mutts predictive message board text service

Give it a rest you daft bugger it's his 1st game for us.

Correct mutley cat, was trying to be polite!!!

How anybody can judge a player on one game i will never know. Why do we turn our players so quickly for?

For the love of god give him a chance to at least settle in, then after half a dozen games there is no clear sign of him offering anything then make a comment.

I for one am glad NGB4C posts on here. It is then that I come to realise that no matter what I may be thought of or called, with him around I can take comfort in the knowledge of knowing while there is life in him, I and many others can never be regarded in the category of the dumbest person on the planet.

Call yourself a trinity supporter, your having a giraffe, for gods sake give the guy a chance, what did you expect a double hat-trick of tries and ten goals. Together we are stronger....... my 'arris.

I remember when a certain A.Volwes first played for Cas and I couldn't believe he had SOO experience........but after settling in, becoming used to the side he'd joined,............ the rest shall we say is history

That is his first game for us, he hasn't played for months so will be lacking match prctice. His passing wasn't the best but i put this down to a lack of match practice and i think he will improve. Overall i don't think we should be having a go at a player after 1 bad game.

He was at Salford for 2 years did not have 1 good game hes shot bad signing its not 1 bad game its nearly 30+ bad games he looks shot ! ! Rather we played harvey.

Im no way as negative as you. You cant talk ! We had loads of effort today. All im saying Smith looks garbage not just 1 game he has done nothing for 3 years. And if he improves and becomes great for us I will show my ass in the bull ring because he isnt !

How would you know that he has not had 1 good game in two years?

so now your going to tell us that in between being wakies number 1 fan , dining at KFCs and stalking Ted in the M&S dressing rooms you have been taking weekly stats on Mr Smith .