www.skysports.com/story/0,19528, ... 07,00.html How can he be found guilty off kicking out,, but avoid a ban If it was other way round would Scully av only got a fine?

www.skysports.com/story/0,19528, ... 07,00.html How can he be found guilty off kicking out,, but avoid a ban If it was other way round would Scully av only got a fine?

stop crying

I think the lack of response from our fans show what we think of the decision.

Jog On son.

Oh look there seems to be something growing from your forehead, oh it's ok it is just a nob!

If he's more carefull in future and realise's that it was dangerous then i think we can all move on.

Shame we don't have Wigan again, I am sure Scully would made note of what happend

As expected really

what can one say,

this how I see the RFL

Is anybody really suprised at the outcome?

I'm not for one.

Who cares?

It was his first time in front of the judges (i think?) so he was only ever going to get a warning letter. That's not because he plays for Wigan, but because that's how it works. If he does it again then he will be in bother.

Scully should have smacked though either way.

I for one am glad he got off. If he had got sent off or at the very least a sin binning then all well and good. But it doesnt help us one bit banning him now, all it will do is give our rivals a leg up.

Exactly, it would have p!ssed mee of even more if he had got a ban tbh.

I care, given that it happened 41 mins into the game and that we was within 3 points of them, rules are rules, just because it was his first warning doesn't make it right at the very least he should of served a ten min spell in the bin, but we are now out of the cup advantage lost I think

Well maybe, they looked at it and said, Sculthorpe held onto him and lifted the legs after the tackle was complete.

He shouldn't have kicked out but was trying to get a quick play the ball.

They may also have taken into account Lee Smith doing something very similar in last seasons play off eliminator at Headingley and decided that they should be consistent.

your having a laugh held, its fact that wigan in the two games employed a slow the play in the tackle, we didn't kick out did we,
I hope he has learned as the next player might not be as lenient

However the panel did decide that he DELIBERATELY kicked him.

Agreed.

And why kick out like that any way? Could even get your own player.

young kid, very quick, no experience, with time this lad will become a good player for the England, GB squad

Sure will, he looks to have lot's of potential and in both games againts us he looked very good.