That dirty incident did not come into it for me.

Like I said form what I have seen from both players Tony wins the vote hands down.

Now I can see that you are biased as Hock is one of your players!

Not at all i just wonder when the last time 2 non Trinity players were compared on here?

Must be a coincidence though. Nothing to do with the way he played today.

That is why the thread started, why do you seem to find it hard to understand?

Mwildcats is just wanting to know other peoples thoughts as we have now seen both play.

Thats fine, i just find it interesting a thread appears on here comparing 2 non Trinity players after 1 has been the villain of the piece against your own team.

Players are regullarly compared between clubs it and on the relevant boards, it must be a total coincidence it cropped up on here today and clearly Hock is going to get a good reception after most of the "fans" i had the pleasure of being stood near were calling for his jaw to be broken every time he took it up after the Pitts challenge.

Well you think that way



And just a point - I did not start the thread but I can see why it was made.

I appreciate you did not start the thread, and i too can see why it was made.

Many Thanks!

6 Wigan fans been on in total then

no brainer for me this tony by a mile, his off load game is awesome too, n gets thru tons of work, oh n his attitude is dam site better than hocks i cant stand the guy i afraid

No contest, Puleteua by the proverbial mile. Hock plays borderline thugby a lot of the time and is frequently a penalty machine. Not fit to lace Tony`s drinks.

I haven't voted as I really can't decide.

I aren't keen on Hock personally but there are a few Trinity players who
I admire on the pitch but don't like personally.

Hock is a bloody good player IMO but so is Puleteua. So I can't choose.

If you had been beaten by saints you'd have picked hock . your just sore yet, i'm sure it will wear off. Where was pulletua at murrayfield? he didn't do much against us, where hock came up with a good try and some great off loads.

Memo to mwildcats. The next time you want to start a thread about a non Wakey subject please run it past jonh first if it includes a Wigin player. For someone what cannot understand the nature of the thread you seem to be keen to contribute your thoughts' on the matter with at the moment 13 posts. Glad its not bothering you though. And before you start I know its a forum and you dont need permission.

Did you not see either of the Wigan vs Saints games then?

He was crap in both

Live by the sword...

If this was on the saints forum i'd actually care why dont you change tp for one of your own second rowers?

Oh forgot cause there gash

You care enough to post young lad, even though it barely makes sense!!

What doesn't make sense?

He ripped you lot to bits yesterday your fans who have posted in this thread slagging hock off are just bitter

Must be the only Trin fan to have voted Hock. He can be dirty and gives away some stupid penalties but running out wide he's a handful.

Don't care what the guys personality is as long as he does a job on the field

I voted Hock too, yes he may be border line dirty but he has raw agression, he's british andx is only in his mid twenties, he'd be a far better long term option. We lack agression in our pack, only lau really showed any yesterday, we need a big nasty block busting forward in our side.

Oh right, that clarifies everything! We are bitter (even though I couldnt choose ...) and you are a child and biased.

Its all clear now.

Ok name a forward off your team better than hock!

but that would be just a personal opinion, hock can be a devastating player sometimes other times he can be a c0ck

All of them for the next two years at least

What a high horse king warrior just fell off, that must have hurt