on Wish fm the comentator said a Cas player kicked straight into touch, but the linesman said no it bounced infield,can anyone verify this,because from this decision they scored

Absolute disgrace that was.

Right in front of us, it was CLEARLY out on the full, Cas get the scrum much to to the disgust of Finch who went over to Bentham telling him.

Bentham runs over to the linesman and does nothing.

Cas score.

Not bitterness, but we were robbed today and that linesman needs censuring over that decision.

CLEARLY OUT !!!!!!!!!!!

It was a bad call but to say we were robbed is going a bit far. One of our tries involved a clear case of crossing, and if Dixon hadn't slipped we would've lost.

Clear case of crossing ?

Come off it...

I know the incident you mean, first half, the ball went through about 3 more tackles after that, not to mention the players that so called crossed were not in play !

Deacon ( I think ) chucked it to the wing.

Agree. We didnt fail to win cos of that call, but it helped. He was also the only person on the ground who thought they scored their third try.

Was that the one that clearly wasn't grounded?

The only guy in the ground who thought it bounced. Even the inbreds knew.

You had the ref on your side for most of the game, so a 50/50 call finally went our way. If anyone robbed you of the win it was Richards

I still can't believe Richards dropped it.

As for the kick out on the full. The referee got it wrong, but Cas shouldn't have been anywhere near us at that point. Credit to them though they hung in there. I just felt we needed one try in the second half to seal it, but unfortunately we didn't get it.

Considering you had the refereeing decisions all game I find it hilarious you blame losing the game on one decision.

At that stage we were still behind and on our own 40 and eight points behind. Granted it was an awful decision but everything was in your favour at that point (strongest team, eight point lead).

Ultimately, it was your own fault at the end of the day that you screwed up such a lead.

Definitely out (by at least 4 inches).

Even if it bounced it would have been our ball. The linesman said it had flicked a Wigan hand didn't he?

A Cas fan tried to tell us after the game that Chase drop kicked it into touch on the full and in the rules that means it's Cas ball....bonkers!

There's no need at all. Comments like that aimed at your fellow Wigan fans are disgraceful. You should be ashamed.

Hmm just watched it on Sky, you may have a point

It was clearly out by around a meter, I just dont understand how the touch judge didnt see it? Its one of the easiest decisions he had to make all match and he f*cked it up and that was the point where the game turned in Cas' favour IMO. Was the TJ just not looking or did he think it was a penalty kick? Either way he should get a right hammering from his boss for it but we all know it wont even be acknowledged.

Damn right, they wont even look at it.

Funnily enough after watching it on sky as well, I'd tend to agree with your original point.

We wuz ROBBED !!!

I wouldnt like you to measure me up for a carpet

I'd be more annoyed at the Arundel try that clearly wasn't grounded!! The Wigan players had a set to defend after the error by the touch judge, it didn't directly lead to Cas scoring points unlike the Arundel try.

It was the same bloke who incorrectly said a Leeds player was in touch last week. Today's was a shocking decision, it wasn't even close. Think he'll be Touch Judging in Super League next week? Of course he will - there is absolutely no accountability for any of the match officials.

Having said that, I don't think that Wigan were robbed. They got the rub of all the 50/50s in the first half and, for once, were on the good side of one of the most frustratingly inconsistent refs in SL. Just watched the Diskin interview at the end of the Bratfut-Sts game. He's spot on about the officials having too much influence in games.

It wasn't a metre as some of your fans are suggesting, hell the gap between the fence and the whitewash probably isn't even a metre.

I think four inches is a fair assessment.

i'm sure he tapped it before he kicked it aswell --- therefore wigan scrum