I think Madge as them 2 has the first choice on the wings! on Friday Goulding looked as hehad never caught a rugby ball in his lifetime! they must have practised in training and Charnley must have reacted better under the high ball

Pretty sure Goulding picked up an injury against les cats, although he didn't play well anyway. He wouldn't be the first of our wingers this year to play poorly and get dropped.

Goulding was hobbling for a good part of the first half and had to go off injured shortly into the second half so I would imagine he is missing the game due to injury. Based on Charnleys attempts under the high ball so far he is far weaker than Goulding in that departments and has dropped a couple in every game he has played so far. I am surprised though that Roberts hasnt been picked for the right wing spot.

Goulding definately landed awkwardly taking a kick in the second half he struggled to play the ball. Im not sure if Goulding has ever been targeted ny teams before with high kicks, having Gleeson next to him may have made teams think twice, the unsettled centres gives team the target to aim for. It will be interesting to see J Tomkins under a high cross kick

How can you be suprised that Roberts hasn't been picked?

He has not had a good game all season,shakey under the high ball,defense a joke and no confidence running with the ball in hand,for me Charnley has been our best winger all season with just the one blip against Wire,other than that he has been outstanding and deserves his place in the team above Roberts.

Did you watch the huddersfield game? Granted he was playing full back but he returned the ball well, was it the Bradford game that he played ok in and got a couple of tries too? Think you're a bit harsh there, although he hasn't been great!

Marsh as a winger not a centre. Outlandish? I named Sam as a 1 years ago and got slated for the same thing. There's logic in it.

The only thing he has done really poorly was dealing with those bombs in the Hudds game. I'm not sure anyone would have caught them though.

I'm surprised that other teams haven't taken a leaf out of our book, when it comes to Charnleys defensive capabilities.