6 months ago I would have probably said Briscoe but now I would probably say lets stick with Phelps.
Hes a similar player to Briscoe perhaps not as good yet but he does have pace. Plus he is only young yet so is going to get better and better.
To get Briscoe back in Wigan we are going to have to make it worth his while...ie ££££. He'll be on a good wage at KR and they will probably offer him a bigger one to stay on so we will have to beat this to sign him on. Its a short career league and Briscoe is not thick he will do what is best for him and his young family.
To keep Phelps in Wigan we probably will not need to offer him a superstar wage and he is much much younger and potentially better if he keeps improving.
The only other Wigan lad I would want back at Wigan is Shaun Edwards as the coach....oh and maybe Farrell as assistant.