My dad usually comes up with some good calls and predicted him to have a blinder. Unfortunately, i couldnt make the game today and diddnt see him play. Did he do well or not?

Didn't warrant the ridiculous Man of the Match acclaim, IMO, but he did "ok"

Agree with that. Worst MOM call in history.

he got MOTM? my dad said he would

He did well, i'd have him in the team before McIlorum if he keeps it up.

I agree.

Is your dad "Neil Robinson & Associates"?

He had a good game and brought a Celtic player down on his own. Seemed to want to impress.

I know. One whole tackle, all by himself. Hip hip horray.

he wasnt even the best halfback on the field let alone mom !
sam outshone him for all of the time he was on the field.

smith was adequate against an appallingly poor team.

Very strange call.

No, Ashtons of Standish Ltd, had a sponsor around the west stand last season, but thats irrelevant. He comes up with wierd calls. Got all the penalty shoot-outs in the FA cup game right today

I thought Mr Smith deserved is award, Fair play to Robinson

Saying that the guy still can't tackle and will get trounced if he plays against Staints

did anyone else notice the quite vocal disaproval (where i was in the east stand anyway) when motm was announced,speaks for itself i think

more than quiet disapproval - i would say it was a concerted mumbling of "what the feck ?????"

MOM in the most boring game of rugby I have seen for a long time. The best part was the basketball after the final whistle.

The two lowest points of the game for me were:

1) Kicking, where has Richards kicking gone?
2) Players not playing to the whistle, a good few occasions when the ball was knocked on the players just stopped if it were a game against a better side lots of ground would have been lost.

I admit it. It was me who made him MOTM. Here's why.

He was the only one who didn't make any silly mistakes. Phelps had a good un, but he childishly let their first try in, and cost me about £50 in lost winnings, so he wasn't f*cking getting it. Our forwards were ordinary. Richards was a contender, but he missed loads of goals. Leuluai was OK. Basically no one stood out. Our best players, actually, were the ones who were used as interchanges. Picking one of them would be a bit like picking James Roby for Man Of Steel.

There were two clinchers, however; One of the girls fancied him, and the other was that I fancied meeting him to see if he really was a bit - erm - challenging, given that the MOTM is obliged to come and talk to the people in the Prawn Sandwich lounge, where I was. I'm happy to say that he is a character, but was utterly charming and friendly.

Plus, I paid about a grand for the privilege, so I'll pick who I damn well like. Irrespective of how they play. That said, one of the girls likes Gaz Hock, and I actually decided before the match that I would pick him just for her, but sadly, he was sh i t, and I couldn't justify it.

In any case, I'm sure that you seasoned supporters know very well by now that the MOTM award is never accurate, probably due to the copious amounts of alcohol served in the Prawn Sandwich lounge.

Personally mate I thought your decision was spot on.

His defence didn't stand out as much as he was defending outside Gleeson and so had cover. (see Sean Long at Stains)

Ball in hand he dictated the play and laid on 4 tries. 2 directly and 2 by creating the space with a quick ball. When Phelps knocked on over the line it was a split second ball. He spotted the gap and ran to the opposite side of the ptb to what he was, took the ball off Piggy and ALMOST put Phelps over. Had the pass been slightly later it was try time.

Probably the first time he's played behind a dominant pack and he controlled.

Smith was good.

To say Hock was bad though is harsh. He gave them nightmares running with the ball they couldn't bring him down.

I tried that, but they said no. Such was the shortage of MOM contenders, I wanted to pick Ganson, but they said no as well. They wouldnt even let me pick a Celtic player.

Speaking of the cheerleaders, though, I was in the tunnel at half time after meeting Harrison Hansen, and they walked past. They're nicer up close.

I agree about it being the worst MOM seen at the JJB for a long while.

He had a steady game, but nothing that stood out to make him MOM. Like the team as a whole lets see how he goes against better opposition.

Man of the match implies said person must have balls.

Fair enough pal. I'm glad you agree, though I happily admit my choice was more down to luck than design.

Agree with every word. It was a toss-up between Coley and Smith IMO.