All this bickering over something purely hypothetical. Let's see what happens on the pitch in 2014.

When did I write off Green and Smith?

Again, when have I said yours isn't be best? Are you really that stupid or just ignorant? I am arguing the fact you said it was head and shoulders above the rest. FFS!!!

Also, when did I slate Smith? You are definitely getting me mixed up with someone else.

Think before you type next time!

Is there really any need to take such an aggressive tone?.. It's very easy when hiding behind your keyboard...

Yes there is a need when I have said several times what my point is but somebody continues to completely ignore that.

It's as though people read something and then respond as though they haven't just read what I've said. I didn't think that grown up, reasonable conversation would be too much to ask.....

it quite clearly is!! it just won the double for jebus sake. It was on a thread on the saints board saying you wouldn't want him back and he is average something along them lines.

Well, whether people agree with you or not, "childish", "Ignorant" and "Stupid" are hardly words to use in a, your words, "grown up, reasonable conversation".

You have just made that last bit up. But saying somebody is average is hardly slating them anyway.

You don't seem to get it. Just because you won the double, that doesn't automatically make your spine head and shoulders above the rest for next season. You hardly coasted to the SL title and your cup run-in was easy. I'm not playing down your achievements but you're talking as though Wigan strolled through the season.

Also, your spine has arguably weakened for next year, whereas others have strengthened. So if it wasn't head and shoulders above the rest in 2013, it certainly won't be in 2014.

Please tell me what you don't understand about what I have just written. And please read it properly.

They are when necessary. I wanted to know if dubairl either was choosing to ignore my point of view or didn't understand it.

BTW, our spine IS head and shoulder above anybody else in SL...

Hope this does not help your blood pressure...

Nice one. I give up talking to you, you're a waste of time.

Correction, i'm childish... Your words..

honestly answer the question do Wigan have star players or are they just better than other teams because the play to really good structures?

Of course Wigan have some star players, I have never ever suggested otherwise. You are completely changing the argument now though. I can't tell if you're actually on the wind-up here it's getting that bad.

That for you is a classic.
pot/kettle



Unbelievable.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

That's all we need, somebody has put 10p in you. This thread really has hit rock bottom.

What do you make of Kyle Amor?

a bit of both really, but i do truly believe Wigans spine is the best in the league.

But by how much!!! Head and Shoulders, gnats nadger????????

Haha fair enough. I think we've taken this particular debate as far as it can go!

Average, but that doesn't make him poor does it?

When did Wigan go full time pro?

I think we have, if we had the same opinions you would support Wigan because there is no way i would support saints.

by a midgets shoulder to a giants head.

No not necessarily.

How do you think he did whilst at Wigan? Did he impress and do well or was he just average? It can't be both old chap....

And stop editing your comments in order to avoid the issue.

looked a monster during the "will he go back to leeds or won't he" then signed permanent contract at wakefield and looked decent.

He's better than decent IMO.

Anyway the reason I'm asking Rogues is because he was completely and utterly shown up and embarrassed a few weeks ago, when his anti-Saints hypocrisy was revealed for all to see.

Just after Saints signed Amor, Rogues wanted to tell everyone that would listen how distinctly average Amor was when on trial at Wigan and he was glad Wigan hadn't signed him this year. However, another eagle-eyed poster then reminded everyone of Rogue's comments a couple of years ago, when he was telling people that Amor really impressed whilst at Wigan and he'd be keen for Wigan to resign him.

He lost any little credibility he had left that day.