Quote ="The All New Chester Wire"I've now watched the match again....
Briers should not have been sent off. He didn't hit him from behind. He "lashed out". What a ridiculous fuss.
The pass from Waktins was NOT forward; the next one might have been but we've got away with many like that this year.
Westwood may have grounded the ball - who knows. Hence BOTD.
The commentary team were nowhere near as bad as I expected from the reports on here.
We won
'"
I agree with you on the title of the thread. It’s all a load of hot air.
However, Briers should have been sent off under the current nanny state rules of the game. I don’t think that is in doubt.
In the eyes of most, including myself, it was harmless handbags and was more amusing than anything else. Although not half as amusing as the hyperbolic reaction it’s garnered from fans of other clubs (I mean grade E-F, rather than grade A – glory be!).
I think it was the correct common-sense call, but the rules would state otherwise.
It was a forward pass. A bad one: well, two bad ‘uns, actually.
I understand physics and the principles of the ‘backward through the air, forward to the eye’ phenomenon, but referees do not have the benefit of replays to determine what is correct. To the naked eye it appeared to be forward a mile and I think it should be given on that. We don’t need DRS and Hawkeye to scrutinise run-of-the-mill decisions in rugby league; just common sense.
We have got away with a lot worse this year and we shouldn’t have been allowed to.
Westwood had probably stopped moving before he got it down at the end, but who knows? Would I have been happy if that try had been awarded against Warrington? No.
Was it a try? Probably not, but, like you say, benefit of doubt could, and ultimately did, apply.
I just don’t want to face Leeds again next Thursday. They will use any perceived injustices from last weekend and, allied to their usual play-off semi-final motivations, I then fancy them to turn us over. We have to use common sense and choose the winner of Huddersfield/Hull, whether it goes against the grain of previous years’ club call selections or not.