So three years later he has a poor game and we 'should have listened to Saints fans'? He was at hooker for periods last night, and helped win us the Cup from stand-off, so I reckon we've had good value from Vinnie, even if this turns out to be his last season with us.

Vinnie was terrible. Thankfully his mistakes didn't ultimately cost us the points.

You can't compare Myler to Nat Wood, there is simply no comparison. Wood was a hard working reasonable player, but to give him legend status is ridiculous. Myler is at the start of what will hopefully be a very long and successful career and probably will reach legendary status by the end of it.

Im not comparing the 2 as such, just stating that we haven't really had a decent scrum half since Nat wood.

He was a top bloke, who did a great job for us. Ok not a legend I agree wrong choice of words but was a great distributor and runner of the ball, something which we've missed these last few years.

Having myler also free's up briers to do what he does best.

Bring on the pies!!!

Wood was a hooker playing out of position.
Loved him at the club but he was never a proper scrum half

Classic Mathers

Give the lad time

Whilst he may have had a bad game yesterday, I disagree with that comment can I ask have you only recently started watching Warrington Wolves or do you attend blindfolded.

Mr Parrot obviously doesn't watch Warrington very often. I seem to recall Vinnie Anderson having a really good game and scoring what was probably the decisive try at Wembley.

i have had a season ticket for 5 seasons jsut to let you know. ok can you name some memorable moments he's done since signing, although he scored a try at wembley i can't remember much more. id rather have clarke tbh at least he tries.

Yeah plus his hatrick last year at the HJ, his length of pitch tries at the Millenium Cardiff and Bradford to name just a few.

Were you at Cardiff in 2007? 95 yards straight through the defence to score. He may not have played that well yesterday, but to accuse him of not trying is ridiculous. Anyone found wanting in that respect will be given short thrift by Smith and I rate him as a better judge than you.

stuff that not many people remember. i don't know if you watched the game last night but he was dreadful, didn't look atall interested and if people don't want to play for WIRE as far as im concenered they can go. however im pretty sure Che will see sense and this will be his last season



.

Iswt.

This is getting almost 'Pythonesque.' Apart from his hat trick last year, scoring the decisive try at Wembley, several long range scores, and playing reasonably well in at least 6 positions, what has Vinnie Anderson ever done for us?

Debateable to say the least.

Read my original post again....I disagreed with your comment that he has "not done much since he signed from Saints" not your comments about how he played last night. HTH



I will reiterate what I said, in that I disagreed with that comment and posted above why I believe that Vinnie has been given unwarranted abuse by yourself.

I don't agree with the abuse that Penny gets on here but ya know... least the lad tries.

Can anyone honestly imagine VAnderson now scoring a length of the field try? Time for McCarthy now I reckon. And with regard to Mathers that was a horrendous mistake from a nothing kick, Sherwin couldn't believe his luck. I can't help but feel he will cost us a crucial game with such basic errors.

however i can image penny scoring a length of the field try

Mark, you are probably right, he won't, and he did have a poor game last night. However he has been useful for us and for someone to accuse him of not trying is just ridiculous.

Is this how you reply when your proven incorrect, change the subject...



Maybe you should remind yourself [url=http://superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?season=2009&stat=offload&hs1=2009&hp1=1118&hs2=2010&hp2=206here[/url

I will again repeat this is not a discussion on his performance last night, its about your comment on him doing very little since signing from Saints.

probably, he is. and he didnt try hard enough last night no. nobody says anything about all the Penny slaggers.

Vinnie had a poor game last night by his standards and if the truth betold he is approaching the final curtain of his top flight career. However to say that he has done nothing for the wolves is both disrespectful, hurtful and not to mention total poppycock. When he leaves he can do so with his head held high.

Well said Brucey, you are absolutely right.

What a load of tosh you lot chat. We all have bad days and as a team WE warrington wolves won the game. Get a grip. It does my head in when people slag players off for a few errors. Thats life. If they didnt have the attitude,abilaty or didnt want to be at the club Im sure Mr Smith would not have them here. Does it make you a less of a fan if you dont go to the away games? does it make you less of a player if you have a bad game/20 mins. Support the team good and bad times..... Home and away