At the end of the day people will like different styles of wingers and players, Henri Fa'afili and Ade Gardner scored plenty of tries but both were/are fairly ordinary RL wingers who were fortunate to play outside great centres.

I'm not a fan of Joel Monaghan, thats nothing personal, its just his fairly laboured style that doesn't grab me, he also doesn't beat the first man anywhere near enough when returning the ball, his line breaks are collectors items. He's no Chris Hicks thats for sure, Hicks could do all of what Joel Monaghan does now plus a lot more.

one thing about Joel is his anticipation and he NEVER gives up on a kick.. he has also developed a finishing style which means he rarely puts a foot into touch.

That last try was a great moment. Thought he'd missed his chance by not challenging for the kick first time.

wonderful player and his trys per match is truely exceptional.if he played for saints or leeds we`d have them 2 off sky creaming themselves every week just like they do over roby and sinfield

Joel is slow for a winger but has lots of other attributes including great strength and a good leap.

Hicks has / had the lot.
Now he really is one of our best wingers in the SL era.

wasnt hicks a speedster in nrl? he was a great finisher but didnt know much about him in his time in nrl heard he did 100m in 10. summit?