Superb tonight me thinks, take a bow son.

His form is continuing to improve every week

He was more impressive than Tony P, who seems to have fallen away somewhat over the last few weeks.

I'd agree with that tony hit the ground running, but has slowed. He sometimes seemed to be carrying an injury?

Is it just me or has anyone else noticed that tony p don't play well in close games?

When we get on top he seems up for it but when it's tight goes missing.

He has gotta play prop so he has to be more involved.

I think it may be how he is being played. He is being used as a prop when he is a outside second row who can cause all sorts of damage as the second phase of an attack. IMO he is wasted at prop, but the current situation with cayless means we need him as prop as he is better than Hargreaves et al.

He got to play prop to help jammer.

Tony p and jammer are the only good go forward we have.

When tony p is prop he has to get involved in the game but in back row he just goes missing.

I think that thug bailey did maurie a big favour by knocking him out coz he played well since.

Think it woke him up.

Oh i am sorry i forgot its against the rules to do big hits on Saints players these days it was shoulder and your not still going on about it on here are you.

Jesus wept just dismiss Paul Clough why don't you. Complete lack of knowledge shown here. Clough's hard yards this season have been invaluable.

Sorry pal I didn't know clough was a prop.

Clough has been fantastic this year
Why he has been overlooked for the elite squad is anyones guess

We are talking about where tony p is best to play.

The point I was saying is tony p makes jammers job easier because he makes good yards.

Clough makes good yards.

Clough's made more metres this season than Puletua and has been pretty much used as an extra prop on the field of play by Mick.

Nothing short of a disgrace. For mine Clough has been awesome this year, one of the first names on the teamsheet and probably player of the season for the S men thus far.

Thanks for making the point for me



When tony p plays in back row he goes missing.

When he plays prop he makes more yard because he get more involved.

Puletua was brilliant in the second half at Catalan, so the talk of him going missing in tight games is rubbish.

It's strange really as tony p played prop for the last 2 years in the nrl.

Puletua has been excellent full stop. Graham, Puletua and Clough have been excellent up front thus far and with Fa'asavalu consistently providing quality impact of the interchange bench we are in good shape. Unluckily with the injury of Cayless we have been one quality forward light.

Can't comment on that as I didn't go France.

What was score at half time?

22-10 to Catalan. With Bryn injured, Tony moved to prop and was probably our best player.

That's what I'm saying!

He is a prop.

Thank you

I thought at times tonight Maurie was doing an impression of Meadowlark Lemon, such were his ball handling skills.

Clough just gets better and better. Love the way he pushes those extra two or three metres on every carry as if his life depended on it.