Quote ="Mugwump"Indeed, I'd argue Wigan have produced more SL players than Leeds and Bradford.
Number of Leeds titles: 5
Number of Bulls titles: 4.
I'm not denigrating youth development. But to suggest such is "essential" does not seem in line with results.'"
Leeds, who have won 5 from the last 8 titles have produced an awful lot of youngsters.
Hall, BJB, possibly Ablett, Sinfield, McGuire, Bailey, JJB, Clarkson and Burrow are all from their academy.
Hardacker was signed as a youngster a la Wilkin and I'm not sure where they got Kirke from, but I'm pretty sure they developed it.
When Bradford were winning they had a lot players coming through, including Peacock and Fielden, two fo the best forwards at the time. Paul Deacon, Leon Pryce are other stars, and their system developed Robbie Paul but they had quite a few young forwards come through as well, such as langley, radford(?) and parker.
What a quality academy gives you is a pool of players to start off with. There's never enough quality out of contact to make a top team from, plus we've the salary cap to contend with now, which doesn't help.
It may not be the be all and end all, but it gives you a massive head start.