Quote ="Stirlingshire Saint"I go the other way, if they are good enough then theyre old enough and deserve a go.'"
I'd agree with this approach. At academy/reserve level what you have essentially is potential, for first grade level playing. If, as Bennett says in that rather good article, the young person has the attributes - which is, the potential - then that young person should be given the opportunity to discover whether he and the coach can turn the potential into a successful professional career. At the moment, our guys Lomax, Wheeler, Ashurst, etc are mainly potential. They are each showing individual moments of, quite frankly, gifted play but they are only moments because the potential has yet to be converted into actual play at that standard. That will take a long time and once the initial adjustment to first grade has been made, they will continue to develop for years afterwards. In fact, professionals no matter what they do never stop learning, adjusting and developing their skills IMO.