How many will vote for Ian Kirke ????











[url=http://www.therhinos.co.uk/news/17424.phpVOTE HERE[/url

So far 2% have

Always tricky is this. I suspect there may have been better options in the past, but the best of those I've seen play was ALi Lauititi, so he has to get my vote, since I can't really vote for a player I never saw.

How do we decide whether somebody was an 11 or 12, out of interest? Did they already poll for 11, and were Paul Dixon and Roy Powell not eligible here?

Pity Richie Eyres didn't make it to 100 games, as he would clearly have won if he had....

Are we having a vote for 13? Can't really see the point if I'm honest.

I dunno, I mean, Garry Divorty will certainly win, but somebody else might get a few votes.

Why isn't Gareth Ellis in that list?

I would guess that having played the 2005, 2006 and 2007 seasons, he wouldn't have reached 100 appearances. He'd need just over 33 per season, which I don't reckon many players manage in 3 consecutive seasons.

And 2008. He's eligible. SL stats has him at exactly 100 appearance but there's no Play Offs or Cup in that so he'll be over 100. Wiki has him at 109.

Not sure why he's not in it. Unless he was in the "Number 11" list and they've just split the recognised Second Rowers in half instead of using numbers?

he appeared on the No.11 list.
Even President Harry Jepson OBE selected him as the greatest No.11

Oh yeah. Good point.

Dunno then.

I'm a little confused as to the inclusion of both Rayne twins as "predominantly playing 12". I know they were twins and easily confused but.....WTF?

[size=50Especially as Keith rapidly moved to 8 and I remember Kev with the 11 shirt.[/size

Likewise, Ellis in the "11" lot, when he wore 20 (2005) and 12 for his other three seasons at the club.

I understand the system of selecting the greatest ever Leeds team is not entirely down to this fans vote and its down to Harry Jepson and a panel having final say.Hving looked at this online vote fans have voted for players of this era of the last 10-12 years etc..I go back a bit further and I missed Arthur Clues ,however based on what I heard over the years and read and the esteem he is still held I voted for Clues.There are lots of players down that list who didnt get a vote who were excellent number 12s i.e Bernard Poole ETC.I am looking forward to the final selection

You've got to feel a bit sorry for Jamie Jones who probably would've stood a decent chance based on his consistency and dedication alone, and yet is put in a category with Ellis who never even wore 11 at Leeds. Ouch.

Gareth Ellis at Leeds:
SL Regular Rds - App 100, Tries 23, Goals 1, Points 94
SL Play Offs - App 9, Tries 1, Goals 0, Points 4
Challenge Cup - App 11 + 1, Tries 3, Goals 0, Points 12
WCC - App 2, Tries 0, Goals 0, Points 0

Total - App 122 + 1, Tries 27, Goals 1, Points 110

Graham Eccles got my vote.

good choice

Had I seen him play I am sure I would have gone for Arthur Clues, but I have stuck to players I watched regulary and so my vote was for Bob Haigh who forme just pipps Graham Eccles

Despite him being an 11 I'd probably agree from those I've seen.

Don't really understand why some Leeds' so called greats don't have full christian names. It's almost as if the list makers have a list of names and positions and not much else to go on.

A fully fit prime Ali is up there as one of the best players I've ever seen. He's certeinly the forward I have enjoyed watching most of the years.

Forward I have enjoyed watching the most was Hanley. Even if his best days were behind him when he finally arrived at Leeds, he was phenomenal.

It will be interesting to see who gets the 13 shirt, there are some strong candidates...

I'm a Wiganer but i always thought Eccles was a good player for you he alway played 2 stone above his weight, was his 1st name Graham?

correct Graham IS his name

got to be sinfield surely

got to be honest dont remember his 1 goal