Im glad after 8 pages we got to the same place we got to in October when we first discussed this

1. Zak Hardaker
3. Kallum Watkins
4. Joel Moon
5. Ryan Hall
6. Danny McGuire
7. Rob Burrow
8. Kylie Leuluai
9. Paul McShane
10. Jamie Peacock
11. Jamie Jones-Buchanan
12. Carl Ablett
13. Kevin Sinfield
14. Stevie Ward
15. Brett Delaney
17. Ian Kirke
18. Chris Clarkson
19. Mitch Achurch
23. Brad Singleton
26. Liam Sutcliffe

another 60 point beat down??? Rangi named in 19 so not sure whats happening there.

Probably this

Hardaker
Watkins - Ablett - Moon - Hall
Sinfield - McGuire
Leuluai - Burrow - Peacock
Delaney - Ward/Achurch
JJB

McShane - Kirke - Singleton - Achurch/Ward

............

With that 19 though I think we could afford to rest JJB and start Ward at Loose and put Clarkson on the bench.

The only thing of interest about Friday's game... apart from the cloud formations... is the attendance.

That says a lot more about you than it will do the state of the game or the Challenge Cup......and not in a good way.

The attendance will say a lot more about the stay-away season ticket holders

That they have a life and have opted on this occasion to do something else on a Friday night? Yeah it still says more about you

Perhaps it says even more about the lives of my regular online stalkers? Like you for example

I'm just giving you the help your 'desperate for attention' style of posting asks for, clearly an area you mustn't get any of away from the keyboard

So who is going?!

You need to stalk JP instead because [url=http://loverugbyleague.com/blogpost_602-jamie-peacock-column:-time-for-super-league-to-take-action.htmlhe doesn't believe SL is "super" any longer either[/url.

Top 5 play-off system and a return to P&R by plenty

How would a 10 team league work with regard fixtures?
And why would a 2nd 10 team league be viewed as part of SL rather than a 2nd division?

Why don't you ask JP himself?

I haven't advocated 10 teams.

An increasing number of people (including JP) believe the current structure is broken and that there must be change before it's too late.

No you tried to use JP's article to back up your own view that there should be a return of P&R and 5-team playoff. But Peacock only advocated a return of those principles within a licensed 2 leagues of 10 team structure. So either you agree with the principle of 10 team leagues or Peacock's article doesn't support your view.

Peacock is advocating a return to P&R.


Peacock is also advocating a 5 team play-off system.


He also admitted there are flaws in any proposal (that would include his own) but reckons [i"we have enough smart people within the game to iron them out"[/i. They'll have to get rid of the current incumbents at the RFL first!


Mutual support for the return of P&R alongside a 5 team play-off system is not dependent upon mutual support for the principle of a 10 team league.

HTH

And that has WHAT to do with a Challenge Cup tie between Leeds and Castleford at Headingley???

Allegedly Rangi's last game for Cas Vegas, should add some spice.

I've heard several stories from different folk - some saying he's had his last game already, some, like yourself, saying that Friday will be his final run out for Cas and others saying he's going no-where.

Without Chase Cas will really be on their arris.

Without Chase, the Super League competiton is diminished also. On his game, he is the most magical player currently playing in this comp.

He does believe Super League is still super. Read it again, without making things up to try and fit your own bias.

Wrong William, Peacock is advocating a return of P&R only between a 2-tier, 20 team SL that is licensed. Peacock is also only advocating a 5 team playoff system in a 10 team league.

Peacock's support, from that article anyway, most certainly is dependent on the principle of a 10 team league.

You got carried away there didn't you? You should've read the article properly.

Completely disagree but that aside he doesn't have those "magical days" consistently enough and even more so at International level to warrant the hype imo.