I thought of Lovegrove and Netherton as primarily 2nd rowers, at the start of the season, but they have to a greater or lesser extent played as props. So even if one or both get new contracts, there may be a need for a new back rower - especially if Gene calls it quits.

On the other hand Walker will play in the back row next year, I assume, and Taylor sounds like he has a lot of promise. So unless Murrell starts spending a significant amount of time at hooker, we'd surely only need to bring one in.

In yesterdays League Weekly Justin says he would like Stan to stay another season, but its too early for the club or the player to enter into talks about a new contract just yet. I hope he stays for one more season.

I'm sorry I have to disagree; I thought this season was a season too far; another would be taking the proverbial. I hope we find Stan a coaching role.

newts would be wasted at prop.....its a hooker we need and not someone who can just fill in

Fully agree that Clint is wasted at prop. Been quite noticeable the games he has had less impact is when he has been playing prop.I have said a few times lets give Liam Watts some game time even if it is from the bench IMO he is better now than Mills will ever be.

Don't get me wrong i like Liam Watts and think he has a big future but what i've seen of him this season in the reserves he hasn't been that good. I am though prepared to say its more down to the poor quality of the reserve grade and the players around him more than anything else but to say he is better now than David Mills is way off the mark.

Gilmour has signed for Huddersfield, for next season.

[urlhttp://www.examiner.co.uk/huddersfield-giants/huddersfield-giants-news/2009/07/14/huddersfield-giants-sign-st-helen-s-gb-centre-lee-gilmour-86081-24144590/[/url

We missed out on this one

fc were interested in gilmour a few seasons ago, the reason he chose not to move to hull was the location, i guess some players just don't want to up sticks and move east

Good move for Gilmour and a good signing for Hudds. He's not the sort of player we need, though.

Id have taken him in a shot.
Good signing for Hudds.
The relocation point is a good one, some players just dont fancy living round this way.

Ditto.

Big, fast, hard as nails, knows where the try line is and is used to winning.

see what you mean, why the hell would we want such a player

Good signing for Huddersfield. I think JM's comments about Mannering not being the sort of player we need (in terms of position, not quality!) apply to Gilmour too.
If the net change to the squad is a hooker-cum-halfback in for a prop leaving, I think we will have a good balance.

seems that good authority you heard about gilmore from..aint that good after all..

Quote ="RIGSBY"seems that good authority you heard about gilmore from..aint that good after all.. '" Lets see if the below, which is also from a very reliable source is also just hot air !! viewtopic.php? ... highlight=

Quote ="RIGSBY"seems that good authority you heard about gilmore from..aint that good after all.. '" Lets see if the below, which is also from a very reliable source is also just hot air !! viewtopic.php? ... highlight=

Quote ="MR BOJANGLES"Lets see if the below, which is also from a very reliable source is also just hot air !! viewtopic.php? ... highlight='" Your a bit behind the times, Morgan has already said Diskin will NOT be a Rovers player next season as he is not interested.

Quote ="MR BOJANGLES"Lets see if the below, which is also from a very reliable source is also just hot air !! viewtopic.php? ... highlight='" Your a bit behind the times, Morgan has already said Diskin will NOT be a Rovers player next season as he is not interested.

Another one bites the dust then !!

I love it, and I quote 'Defo for next season !!!'

why dont you listen to what i tell you,i told you 3 weeks ago about Gilly going to the Giants ,some people just never listen,if i can help you in the future dont hessitate to ask.

Scott hkr,mate you dint miss out because you were never in the running.

can you tell me when hudds are next going to be onside so i can get a picture

Go back and check your source dude, it's a Leeds fan that said that.

You wanna get them mutton chops off your ears dude so you can listen correctly. It was a KR fan on the Leeds board dude !!

I supose its when they beat you again