He did. I'm not been funny or anything but Saints played terrible and you only just won. Kelly was shocking in defence and hardly made any ground on wilkin who is not very quick at all.

On a serious note, Kelly is doing way, way too much defending. He's very enthusiastic and is not as bad in the tackle as some people are saying but he is very small.

He should be defending on the wing for tackles one to three/four depending on field position. He's too important in attack for him to be wasting his energy tussling with second rowers.

I was surprised when i watched the game back that brian Carney mentioned that Kelly played a lot of his junior rugby in the forwards and perhaps likes getting stuck in with a lot of tackles

He did and I think he needs protecting from himself, I don't want to see an energetic half back like Kelly making or being involved in more than about a dozen tackles a game.

Kelly should be all about broken field running and sniping out opportunities, we've got players like McCarthy and Donaldson to do the donkey work, which is equally valuable and they do it better.

Jordan cox is our best player for donkey work, just needs to cut out the horse play!!!!

Agreed, we said at the game on Friday that Kelly's energetic and off the cuff play even sucks campo in at times and he starts throwing cut out passes and off loads i was kind of hoping Campos calm calculated play would rub off on Kelly but seems to be the other way round, being 24-12 up and right in front of the sticks and campo goes wide being a prime example