Irreplaceable

Absolutely outstanding - he really is a freak of a player. Big big loss for us.

Massive loss. Nice to hear "There's only one Willie Manu" ringing out from the faithful.

Awesome performance tonight, Manu and Ellis would have been a great combo.

Leeds have got a great player on their hands!

11-Manu
12-Ellis
13-Westerman

Whilst i'm a Wigan fan and love our back row of Hock, Hansen and Lockers i'll admit if you could keep Manu next season yours is as good as ours and any other in the league.

If you had Tickle coming off the bench as well it's the sort of squad that puts you into finals.

He was outstanding. As someone said, he didn't deserve to be on the losing side.

absol brill, cant we keep him PLEASE

Class player who will be missed but was never worth a 3 year contract.

Unplayable at times yesterday, massive loss to the club.

Can't help thinking this might be a feck up by McRae. Fully agree that you have to pay players what they're worth. But if the Saints deal fell through we should be pulling out all the stops. The guy's a freak.

How Dobson got M.O.M over Manu is another of lifes great mysteries.

the same McRae that has lost us Turner as well, the useless McRae that ruined Salford.


How much longer Gentle allows him to interfere will be interesting to see, but I wish he was nowhere near my club, he was a problem when he was here last time and he's an issue now.

Not really. manu was on the losing side

non of the hull palyers did

You know im starting to think McRae is the problem too and is he actually needed anymore? Yes it was good for him to help appoint a coach and help Pearson in his early days but we now have a ful time CEO and Head coach so McRae just isnt needed

he's an arrogant individual, as I say, I wonder how long Gentle will put up with it, he doesn't like Turner (hence him going to Saints), AP is no mug, but he does seem to be daft to listen to McRae who has done nothing in SL for ten years.

Nice guy is Bomber but I think he is over exposed on SKY - is this his priority?

Said all the time it be massive loss with ellis coming or not

Not sure if it came across on TV or not, but during the first half the fans were singing 'there's only one Willie Manu' and Manu looked quite moved by it, and clapped the fans.

I hope and pray that the longer the silence goes on, the more likely it is that he will stay. Gareth Ellis is a massive signing for the club, but there simply isn't another Willie Manu out there in the world of Rugby League.

Maybe we'll hear something after the Saints game.

If it works we need to be singing the same to Moa and Tickle aswell!

manu just seems to get better and better

Hasn't Pearson already said that he's gone next year.

the club said that he had rejected their 'final offer' and was free to talk to other clubs...but this was weeks ago, and he hasn't signed for Saints as everyone expected him to. The longer it goes on, the more likely it is that both sides will come to an agreement IMO.