for accuracy

Berrigan hasn't lived up to the billing he was given, but there is time.

Which muppet put Divet?! Were you only 4 at the time he played?

Greenhill for me. The only thing he did of any value was to smack Barry Ward and allegedly throw a cocky current winger through a panto-named pub window.

I like him again now I read this!

Did he ever actually play a game?

I thought Jason temu was a good prop forward. One of the better of the boys to play in the early superleague team. Quite similar type of player to leulaui at leeds now!

Don't like to have a pop at any b&w but I never saw this guy as someone who tried to earn his shirt so I don't think of him as a b&w... Hunte... wins hands down (during my lifetime) - absolutely no-one else comes anywhere near.

I agree with that.

1.
2. sing
3. hunte (gb international at the time)
4. calland (key member of the bulls side)
5.
6.
7.
8. okesene (reputation as a fearsome forward)
9. berrigan (aussie and soo player)
10. jones (star of welsh ru)
11. booth (i've added this - wembley try scorer and winner with saints)
12.
13.
14. greenhill (added to the bench)

a friendly?

Why not, the thread is about the most over-rated player, Berrigan happens to be SL highest paid import, his game since his arrival would not warrant this title, hence over-rated..we could discuss others but most were not on extraordinary wages

Just because the guy has played in a crap Hull side for the 2 years that he has been here does not make HIM over-rated.

The guy is a class act who gives nothing but a 100% when he is wearing the Hull shirt. He has played injured several times, played several positions (because this was beneficial to the team) and generally been surrounded by dross.

Sure, he has not set the world alight, but Wally Lewis in his hey day would have struggled to shine in the Hull side of the last 2 seasons.

I am sure Berro's class will be a little clearer for the less knowledgeable fans amongst us to see next season.

spot on

Let us less knowledgeable hope so..disagree that he has given 100% on all occasions..Cas are not the best in the league but my word Rangi Chase looked good

A guy who as played out of position (and mostly with pain killing injections) for the last 2 seasons and with a coach that is fecking clueless is classed as over rated.

He certainly did, but he also had team mates who generally played the game with a lot of enthusiasm and commitment. This in-turn gave him the runners and options; something Berrigan has not had the luxury of at Hull, to showcase his skills and creativity. I am sure Berro can do likewise now that he is in a team that should have a positive work ethic and mentality.

Jeff Doyle was quality at that time too, along with James Grant and Paul Sterling we had the best attacking left hand side in the league.

Lets hope so, it may stop him being a piiss head as well

For the wage he demands yes...simplez really!

Those of you that put Daniel Divet did not obviously see him play. And for those going about Marcus Bai, he came with no reputation at the begining of his career, signed by 1 coach not wanted by the next and then went onto great things with the storm.
Some people are just naming donkeys we had signed but for over rated I'd have to go for Matt Calland. Did he only manage the 1 game away at Cas before retiring with injury before popping up somewhere else.

I've not witnessed any of these antics personally, but have heard some of the stories. If these are true, then obviously it is some cause for concern.

But from a personal point of view, what ever he gets upto away from the rugby field I have been happy enough with his efforts on match day's on it.

He could take the easy option and not play (and still get paid) because of the injury he has but instead he puts his hand up week after week to bail the team out, as for the wage he demands we'll see why he does when he is playing HIS position and (hopefully) injury free.

Mind you had the club not given him such a wage and he gone to Wire (like Monaghan) instead, people would be on here moaning how the club are too tight and not willing to pay for quality players.

Correctamundo, well said.

1.
2. sing
3. hunte (gb international at the time)
4. calland (key member of the bulls side)
5.
6.
7.
8. okesene (reputation as a fearsome forward)
9. berrigan (aussie and soo player)
10. jones (star of welsh ru)
11. booth (i've added this - wembley try scorer and winner with saints)
12.
13. holgate (got our loose man - grand final winner)
14. greenhill (added to the bench)

Has Thorman being mentioned

sing, berrigan and greenhill? over rated???



if thats the case you havnt got a clue what your talkin about