Do not want this player anywhere near my team, he's done nothing for Cas this season apart from give away cheap and dirty penalties, bet Cas couldn't believe their luck when he asked to be released.

Was Gentle at Wests when they tried to sign him?

Don't ask me i don't pay attention to NRL



I don't know if this was a rhetorical Question? im unsure

Not rhetorical, just read on his wiki profile that Wests wanted him when he came to Cas. No idea how long Gentle was at Wests, but it's possible if he was involved then that he's kept an eye out for him, that's all.

I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc

I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc

Quote ="Hull of a guy"I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc'" Don't come on here with any of that positivity, it's not allowed

Quote ="Hull of a guy"I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc'" Don't come on here with any of that positivity, it's not allowed

Quote ="Hull of a guy"I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc'" Would be a pretty awesome signing!

Quote ="Hull of a guy"I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc'" Would be a pretty awesome signing!

For those saying that McGoldrick is a penalty machine, according to Opta stats he has only given away 8 penalties in his 17 appearances this season.
If he had been in the Hull squad he would be in drawn 7th place for penalties, alongside Manu and Martin.

I would prefer us to look at other players before him, but if there are issues with Russell's loan (being recalled) and if Horne is having some problems, then he's decent cover for fullback for us for the rest of the season. Experienced and seems committed to his role (has shown good loyalty to Cas in his time there).

He wouldn't be my preference but if he plays for us then he'll get my support, same as anyone in the black and white. Remember, Aspinwall came with some baggage and negativity but has put in some strong performances.

I wouldn't cry and throw my toys out of the pram over this, especially if it allows us to spend more money on other areas of recruitment.

Quote ="Hull of a guy"I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc'" That would be an amazing signing, Marshal and Galloway?

Quote ="Hull of a guy"I don't know if it's been mentioned on here before but I'm hearing that the big NRL prop we've signed for next season is Keith 'Big Red' Galloway from Wests. State of Origin and International honours to his name; would be an awesome signing if true. www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAeKxMo1wzc'" That would be an amazing signing, Marshal and Galloway?

We share this dream my friend

McGoldrick's baggage makes Aspinwall's look like a man bag.

The bloke's a serial cheap shot merchant. Puts a few in every time I've seen him play. And he's a pretty mediocre player overall. The only upside I can see is that he'll be cheap to bin off.

if they are going to get some one for fullback then im sure we have a team in superleague who need all the money they can get they have 2 good fullbacks in kearney and sammut who was a great player at fullback for panthers in nrl why would we get McGoldrick from cas out of his current deal when we could easily go and cherry pick who we want from the bulls and it would make us fc fans alot happier because if this is true its the most shocking and probably weirdest signing hull have made what do we see in him?

If and when this is announced it will be by far and away the worst signing we have ever made. As much as I hate Cockhead at least he has a small amount of talent which would kind of make up for it. McGoldrick has literally no redeeming features. I just can't see any upside at all, especially if the rumoured 18 month contract is correct.

Baffling!

Or lovegrove

i'm sure once the signing is announced he'll become one of the best players in SL so i wouldn't worry too much about it!!

Excellent signing if true. Will fit in well at 1 or 6 and can cover centre.

Good hands, can get through a gap and good defence.

Who's that now?

Agreed, although not my 1st choice target we could do far worse.

another crossed off hulls list.

He who laughs last!

Laughing, not me just glad rovers have secured an extension to one of the best players at our club.

Only as you lost os Paea.



McGoldrick is an awful signing, a really poor signing and I cannot for one minute defend AP or PG on this. It's a shocker, he's been done for the last 3 years.

Did Rhys cross himself off our list and tell us to get lost, then, or did McRae just
change his mind?

Apparently, he was offered a deal by you lot that was better than the one we offered him but Rovers saw sense and improved it. I think it's good news for us as he will only get better as a prop, especially under Sandercock.

Future England prop and a current one for Rovers