Ben Thaler ring any bells?

Didn't mention that we dont blame refs either. Just expect it from both Hull sides at the minute considering SL refs dont give either Hull side anything against the rest of SL.

Very poor performance from Silverwood .
Forward passes week in and week out are not given . Then he rules forward on a perfectly good pass !
Its not often that a ref can have such a bearing on a result but last night he did .
At times I thought Fred Lindop had come out of retirement !

Sorry,can't find a suitable thread to add this but I now know that Paul Cooke left Hull for HKR in controversial circumstances and was playing against his former club because Eddie Hemmings told us last night.He also told us in the previous derby,and the one before that.It's boring now,turn it in EH for goodness sake.

I'm still livid by that decision. Raynor was clearly 5 yards behind Hall and Silverwood could not have been in a better position to see it. That result could have given everybody at the club a lift after another horrendous season and to lose a game on a decision like that is a bitter pill to take.

Thanks to all the supporters on this thread from other clubs who clearly saw the decision for what it was, like a few have already said another rugby league game were the referee once again is the major discussion point!!

We got away with several ball steals as well, apart from the forward pass decision which was ridiculous i think it was fairly even with the calls and for me the Tansey?Calderwood one was spot on. The biggest factor was luck and the bounce of the ball,literally. Thought Cooke did what he does best but i really don't get the fuss with Dobson, apart from his kicking game i don't think he offers a great deal,he's a passenger defensively and offered little with ball in hand. Lovegrove impressed me and thought he was easily the pick of their forwards. After the first 10 minutes i think Vella's yardage was in the minus'.

'Robbed' is an understatement. How much luck did Rovers need to win that game last night. A draw would have at least made sense. Its sickening how 'everything' went the scum's way. A picture-perfect Paul Cooke kick lead to a jammy 2nd try.

The telling moment was our last try that was chalked off for an apparent forward pass, and as if it was a fairy tale for the preston road massive, guess what...a dobbins try straight away.

This is the fact: Hull played with so much passion last night and should of won. We didnt because we were robbed....plain and simple!

That would be 4th then.
As for the rest of your post I suggest you wipe your chin as you are obviously dribbling

camera angles dear boy , sit in the middle of the sofa were your in line with the pass and you will see it was clearly forward, hope that helps !

Er no, but nice attempt

Never a forward pass, and there was a lot of holding down and ball interference not penalised as well. Combined with our kicking game to cost us the match.

But still, enough positives for me to still be happy in all honesty. We looked to throw the ball around and offload, and everyone looked up for it. We also used the bench well for a change too, IMO. Hopefully those aspects will continue, with added support play to go with the offloading. Main things now missing are aggression, organisation in attack, and a kicking game, which should all be aided by the personnel coming in. Finally a glint of things to look forward to.

Rovers had a poor game and yet won.

Hull FC played their best and yet they lost.

Just shows you how far Rovers have come and how much Hull FC have declined over the last 2 seasons.

It was rovers best performance in about 2 months. At least our fans accept we're shiite

Nothing to choose between either side exept for a crap deision by Mr Silverwood which cost FC a draw which I think would have been a fair result. Really enjoyed it on Sky

Best performance?? What planet are you from??

Why do people just assume that if the Raynor try is allowed then the exact same scenario i.e. Webster scoring is guaranteed to happen? If Raynor scores Hull would have been a good chance to win let alone draw.

Tansey was tackled when he passed the ball and Whiting lost it over the line. Only one try was "disallowed" the other two were never tries in the first place.

Technically Raynor never actually grounded the ball when the ref gave the forward pass...

Technically the ref is a to$$er guffaw guffaw

I agree.

Typical Rovers 'rent a crowd' supporters comment!!!
Look at the facts BR....We are a severely depleted team (allegedly low on confidence!!!), We 'outscored' you and your first two tries were lucky and off the back of our mistakes. (Cookies was good though

). We had a perfectly good try disallowed. (weird that only KR fans, Silverwood and Morgan saw different.....The rest of the RL world saw it as a ref blunder!)....You didn't put 50 points past us...as KR fans had been boasting. And most of all.......It seems you are suggesting your lot weren't fired up for a Derby......mmmmmm that can't be good for your play-off hopes...can it. I really hope we can sneak into the playoffs and get you again.....WE WON'T LOSE NEXT TIME......!!!!!

Pathetic decision by Silverwood and I hope he is ashamed of himself when he watches the replay but somehow I doubt it. He has always been a "home" ref because he has no heart and no bottle. If your going to disallow a try for a forward pass you better be damn sure it was forward as any benefit of doubt goes to the attacking team. The pass wan't even flat so for him to have given it forward just shows how poor he is. When will our luck turn in these derby games and we stop getting poor calls against us at crucial times in the game? Having said all of that we just need to work on improving as a side so that luck cannot be the deciding factor anymore. Best team lost yesterday.

Thats just it YOU WOULD, your getting yourselves all excited over a loss look



I would love you in the play-offs, however theres a problem, you wont get anywhere near em

Get over it FFS!

FWIW i thought it was forward

Silverwood is garbage, few weeks ago James Graham had to advise him on the rules of the game


You guys should feel hard done to, to lose to your derby is bad enough, but to lose when you had the upper hand & perfect try ruled out.
But it's what we all expect, Ashley Klein SOS!!