Think Hall has become a Hull FC victim.

Not developing with us and confidence shot. All traits necessary for a great player there but untapped.

Can see him spending a couple of years at a modest Super League club such as Rovers or Salford then being snapped up by a Wigan and coming back to bite us for ever more.

Fair enough but i will take the word of a player over yours.

I don't expect you to 'take my word' for anything. We'll see what happens at the end of the year if Hall is retained (or even if he's not). We have differing opinions and it's possible for that to be the case without resorting to petty little comments about crusty socks and the like.

Who's? Craigs?

Last time i looked it was a opinions board and i gave my opinion....i agree he has to move on as we will ruin him...he knocks on then when he gets the ball people sarcastically cheer.....didnt notice a lot of praise when he out-jumped Richards......Who next for the scapegoat tag...Tansey?Hame?Berrigan?Dowes?Cusack?Radders......they have all had threads of thier own,slagging them off...i try to suppoert the players when they pull the shirt on...yes some arent good enough but slagging them off wont help.

Ha ha.........M.O.M in the 2009 northern rail final was who i got talking to at a family wedding in the lakes.

Giving your opinion would be saying why you rate Hall and why you think those who don't rate him are wrong. Making silly comments about crusty socks and calling people pricks solely because they disagree with your viewpoint is just childish.

Oh do shut up you tart

I agree with the Tansey bit . Equally as bad and will only be a matter of time before he is crucified like motu.

I think Hall has all the potential to be a good SL player, he is never going to achieve it with us though.

whiting, hall and turner all look like they can't defend on the wing for Hull so is it the players or the system?

Calderwood manages it a bit better?

Does he? I honestly can't remember. He's certainly quicker which may get him out of trouble from time to time

Craigs confidence is a shambles now thats the easiest way to describe him, time for a move i am afraid as he will not recover any form at FC as it stands

No one fault other than his own .

Well thats what happens when you get most of the crowd sarcastically cheering and a coach with no confidence in him......yes Hall is to blame as well but still think we could have had a very good player on our hands but a move is the obvious thing to do now.

even after his interveiw on Humberside stating he wanted to stay at Hull and wasnt moving to Rovers the HDM still said he was moving poor kid mustnt know whether hes coming or going with our press

A difficult situation this one....If Craig wants to stay he needs to go on a dual contract imo....that way he can be loaned out play at the level he is at presently and hopefully develop and gain some confidence and build and improve his game.

The right wing spot is a poison chalice!

No service in attack

In defence, you will always be left to your own devices.

Ask Blacklock, Sing, Calderwood etc etc.

Last night Wigan perfectly exploited our frail defensive system.

I doubt he takes any notice of that rag. It's not even good enough to be tomorrow's fish and chips wrapper.

couldnt of wrote it better myself!!!!! its a 17 man team and yet again craig gets the blame, the whole team was crap thats why they were NILL........

Roll on his depart at the end of the season then you will have to find someone else to slag off!!!!

FFS, read the thread. I don't believe there's a single post blaming Craig Hall for the defeat. It might help your argument if you actually read what has been written, rather than what you [ithink[/i has been written.

half the comments on here are blaming Craig!!! are you reading the same as me!!!!!

Ok, quote them.