Why? He's telling the truth.

Agree, I certainly do not recall Washy ever having an outstanding game in an FC shirt.

Quote ="Marfa Manu"Disagree, he is doing fairly well....his stats are not too shaby at all. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2012'" No doubt he's doing well, he always was a 13. My point is he followed the man that had basically ruined any potential he had.

Quote ="Marfa Manu"Disagree, he is doing fairly well....his stats are not too shaby at all. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2012'" No doubt he's doing well, he always was a 13. My point is he followed the man that had basically ruined any potential he had.

Then you have a very poor memory.

I'm not saying he's a bad player, just that he's more suited to the bottom end of SL than the top. Whiting had a poor deal under Agar, but still managed to perform consistently well. Washbrook was never destined to be anything other than solid, IMO.

Go to your sky plus.

If we all want to forget the the last 6 years and pretend we've never seen this style of rl before then fair enough.

When Sharp coached us we played a similar style, we were strong in defnce and used to win the close games. Washy was very good for us, his career went down hill when Agar started playing 'props' at 13.

If you check my posts on Whiting I've always said he could be a good backrower for us, i've likened him to Ellis on numerous occasions, but I aren't going to forget Washy's earlier games for us.

I never saw any thing more than the potential to be a decent player if I am honest, which judging by his stats so far this season he has reached.

Yep, whats your point?

Maybe...all I recall is a few decent games, nothing which was outstanding though.

I disagree. He had some good games, but was never anything special.

Wsahy had some excellent 80 mins games for us.

My Sky+? I don't have any of Washbrook's games for Hull FC on there.

I'm not forgetting his games for us, I just have a much different view of them. He's never been in Whiting's class as far as I'm concerned, but to say he could have been 'our Sinfield' is just laughable.

He was outstanding in numerous games in 2006.

He had some good games. I don't recall him ever having the sort of influence Whiting has had this season.

Thats fair enough Rgx, just my opinion.

I know a few agreed with me, unfortunelny not Agar.

Agar obviously rates him to some extent as he's taken him to Wakey. As you say, it's about opinions, but mine is that Washbrook was always destined to end up where he is.

Now this I don't get, apart from his 2nd spell against Rovers what games has he influenced? He's been very, very good but not influential. Lynch, McKinnon & Houghton have been influential.

On and completely off topic but if you can get it over the internet RGx this may interest you. www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm

On and completely off topic but if you can get it over the internet RGx this may interest you. www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm

I've got to agree with this.

Whiting was a rock but he wasn't great, I even saw someone compere him to Jason Smith.

Again, I'd disagree. I think we look a better side when he's on the pitch. Some of his hits in defence alone have the capacity to lift the side and therefore influence the game. When he comes back for the last twenty, I think it gives us something extra.

To be fair, I think they likened his involvement in Yeaman's try to Jason Smith's style of play, rather than comparing the two as players.

Quote ="Sheldon"On and completely off topic but if you can get it over the internet RGx this may interest you. www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm'" Definitely, cheers.

Quote ="Sheldon"On and completely off topic but if you can get it over the internet RGx this may interest you. www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm'" Definitely, cheers.

Quote ="Sheldon"On and completely off topic but if you can get it over the internet RGx this may interest you. www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm'" Definitely, cheers.

Quote ="Sheldon"On and completely off topic but if you can get it over the internet RGx this may interest you. www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm'" Definitely, cheers.

Whiting had a great game, stepped up the pack really well this season. Him and Aspinwall have done really well since Westerman got injured and between them offer a really good balance.

As for Washy, he was excellent for us at 13 when he burst onto the scene but unfortunately lost him way through a mixture of injuries and Agar.