I believe that's the line they quoted for one of the Liam Watts tackles. Didn't stop him getting a few weeks holiday though did it?

That was my point as to when is an offence actually an offence, as Watts was banned for less at the time and it was deemed he had a duty of care and responsibility to his opponent etc. So have things changed since?

Sutcliffe pretty much straight arms him and makes direct contact with the head. How the RFL disciplinary panel can say its not clear is beyond me unless the panel consists of Steve Wonder, Ray Charles & David Blunkett.

The big issue is the inconsistency week to week in the panel's findings. I don't for one minute think that the panel is in any way biased against any club, but unless I'm mistaken, isn't the panel made up of different people each time, so how can they be consistent over a season?

I think you are right, different people each week, different decisions, totally inconsistent.

A bit like the Referees

Seems consistent to me, Tag’s first game back and reported by Match Review Panel for Dangerous contact, no charge

Good band that Chris

Would be even better if I replace Blunkett with Jeff Healey

Fairly quiet again.... Danny Kirmond (Wakefield) - Grade C Dangerous Contact - 2 Match Penalty Notice Ben Westwood (Warrington) - Grade D Headbutt - Refer to Tribunal https://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_doc ... h%2019.pdf

Fairly quiet again.... Danny Kirmond (Wakefield) - Grade C Dangerous Contact - 2 Match Penalty Notice Ben Westwood (Warrington) - Grade D Headbutt - Refer to Tribunal https://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_doc ... h%2019.pdf

Kirmond should have got a red .

Just out of interest what was Sneyd yellow card for against Wakey was it just for booting theball away? If so how come Hurrell wasn’t afforded the same punishment on last night against Catalan for hurling the ball away and saying a few choice words?

Think Sneyd was yellow carded for
preventing a 20 metre restart and dissent, Hurrell could have been penalised for dissent, if he was penalised I can’t remember.

I thought it was more out of frustration than anything else that he kicked out at the ball, but I guess the outcome was the same.

The SL Stats seem to have taken a backwards step, difficult to find and limited information.

Another quiet week, no mention of Taylor..... https://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_doc ... 202019.pdf

Another quiet week, no mention of Taylor..... https://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_doc ... 202019.pdf

Oh he's in there. Bottom of page 6.

...yes I missed that, I read the Abdull charge and assumed Taylor was the "victim", they usual mention them in the summary, but not always it seems.

Pretty consistent then, this disciplinary process.

you mean, it always has to have Taylor in it somewhere?

On Humberside old pinko couldn’t keep his emotions in check regarding Tag late tackle.

Only 6 sanctions mentioned for last weekend - 5 were hull fc players!

The rfl stats have lost a lot (most) of the detailed info this year, now the disciplinary player/club details have gone the same way, as far as I can tell.

Click on 'Match Review Panel Minutes' and you get this which has everyone detailed:

[urlhttps://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_docs/Match%20Review%20Panel%20Minutes%20-%208%20April%202019.pdf[/url

Quote ="Karen"Click on 'Match Review Panel Minutes' and you get this which has everyone detailed: [urlhttps://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_docs/Match%20Review%20Panel%20Minutes%20-%208%20April%202019.pdf[/url'" Yes, it's the search option I can't find, you could check players and club records going back 10 years or more last week. www.rugby-league.com/the_rfl/disciplinary no longer goes there. =#FF0000edit: found it:.... https://www.rugby-league.com/the_rfl/disciplinary

Quote ="Karen"Click on 'Match Review Panel Minutes' and you get this which has everyone detailed: [urlhttps://secure.rugby-league.com/ign_docs/Match%20Review%20Panel%20Minutes%20-%208%20April%202019.pdf[/url'" Yes, it's the search option I can't find, you could check players and club records going back 10 years or more last week. www.rugby-league.com/the_rfl/disciplinary no longer goes there. =#FF0000edit: found it:.... https://www.rugby-league.com/the_rfl/disciplinary

CCS your clued up on all this disciplinary business, can you tell me the last player apart from Savelio to actually get suspended for tripping, no drug related comments please.

I didn't think it would be possible, but...…

google =#4000BFtripping site:rugby-league.com

finds them.



Using the search facility offered on the RFL website is even easier.

Quote ="ccs"I didn't think it would be possible, but...… google =#4000BFtripping site:rugby-league.com finds them. '" Last one I found was Richie Myler found guilty of the grade A offence tripping , fined £300 but no suspension. https://talksport.com/sport/rugby-leagu ... sit-wigan/

Quote ="ccs"I didn't think it would be possible, but...… google =#4000BFtripping site:rugby-league.com finds them. '" Last one I found was Richie Myler found guilty of the grade A offence tripping , fined £300 but no suspension. https://talksport.com/sport/rugby-leagu ... sit-wigan/

There was just one last year if you count academy matches

...