In all seriousness with no smilies please tell what is amusing?
Have i incorrectly stated a fact that you can laugh at or am i completely incorrect about Hall?
Surely you can add some substance to your comments rather than a icon from the left?

You really want me to do this?

I have already addressed this point in my previous post. I see no point in repeating it.



I have already addressed this point as well. Perhaps you could bring yourself to actually read my posts rather than just responding to them willy-nilly?



I very clearly, and deliberately, referred to Hull FC as a team with top 4 aspirations. We are not yet a top 4 side, and I think we're unlikely to be this season. If we strengthen our squad in the off season, we might be next year.

Is your name Dave then ?

Just a selection of the statements I've enjoyed reading so far.

Quality

Sorry i confused the fact of being in the Top 4 and having the Top 4 as an aspiration, obviously had i read it correctly i would have realised and got your point first time as of course neither Wakefield Nor Harlequins strive for this.
I hope you see my confusion and forgive my rantings!!!

Why not tell me where my statements are wrong rather than just use a little smilie face?

Is Hall not one of the fastest in Super League?
And if not if a SLOW centre who will score 8 try's for us by this stage then good for us.

As for the Morgan comment we had 4 players in the Dream Team under him and 2 making their England debut unless once again im wrong?

On his 2 years previous to joining us did Michael Dobson infact play for the 2 teams mentioned, I would agree before it is brought that he was infact a stand out player for both but gained contract nor made the dream team with either yet did under Morgan!!

And lastly would Hall leave both Yeamo and Manu in his dust then yes he would!!!!

Keep laughing but until you put an arguement against then i must be right or you could just smile

Just so I've got this right....

Hall is fast because he has scored 8 trys?
Morgan has made Newton and Galea into better players but is actually better at bringing the youth through?
Again Morgan has turned Dobson into the player he is now?
Manu is fat?

Hall is fast, however so is Dwain Chambers and they both have the same thing in common they couldn't tackle a sunday dinner!!!


I honeslty am unable to go on further because you are clearly not reading replies from any-one...again is your name DAVE!!! are you Craigs Dad

No Hall is fast because his legs move quick, he scored 8 trys in SL as he is at that standard unless of course he is leaving Hull FC.

Galea maybe not but unless im mistaken Newton did not make the Dream Team in 2008/2009 yet did the year after although you may be right and this had nothing to do with the coach and as such this is why we never (and i mean us all) blame them for anything, as for the youngsters again you would be right that neither Whelham nor Lovegrove have made any improvement in the last 2 years so i accept your arguement.

My point was that Dobbo played for 2 other SL teams and never made the Dream Team but did under Morgs, so you either have to accept one of 2 facts, SL has got worse since Dobbo joined KR or Dobbo has got better since he Joined KR, one has nowt to do with the coach but coaching in general the other has to do with the coach so think before you pick.

I previously appologised for the Manu statement and stated how much i like him as a player!!

Whether or not Hall is fast, he certainly isn't 'one of the fastest in Super League'. And however much of a defensive problem you think he might cause Manu and Yeaman, I feel sure they'd cause him much bigger defensive problems. Manu regularly swats off much better tacklers than Craig Hall.

If Craig is SL standard how come he does not play much ? Maybe the coach see what we see



It will be interesting IF Craig leaves where he goes and how many top teams bid for him don't you agree. Leeds, Saints, Warrington, Wigan, Huddersfield ??? all very doubtful me thinks.

That i defianately agree with however he will not face Manu every week (thank God)!!

Looks like the School kids are home so i will go through it again, Hull FC's top try scorer this year is Bricoe with 11 from 11 games second is HALL with 8 try's from 9 games, dont know what your coach is seeing but its not the same as me!!!

Just for clarity - again - those who don't want Hull to re-sign Hall don't have a problem with his attacking play.

Will you stop banging on about the dream team. Are you saying Newton and Galea are better players now than at any point in their careers. Yes or No?

If yes, you are saying that Morgan has improved players who have played at the top level in Australia, including winning Grand Finals, which would be some achievement in itself but then that is actually nothing compared to the improvement he is responsible for with the young players? These young players are surely world beaters then?

How the frick does Dobson making the Dream Team last year as opposed to previous years mean the overall standard of SL has declined? Maybe 1 other half back in those years had outstanding seasons? Here's another one for you, perhaps the additional year of development Dobson had in Australia (on top of all the coaching he had previous to that) before returning to SL is the reason he is a better player?

Keep em coming though I'm enjoying having a giggle at your expense

Have you joined us because you are banned from the HDM site

When have you ever agreed with your coach?

More than I have agreed with yours

To be honest, talking about Hally, I used to defend and defend and defend him due to his attacking ability. I still maintain that he does indeed have the ability to actually do something that no other player at FC can possibly do. Attacking with flair and beat people with pace. unfortunately, I really now believe that he makes too many errors to justify the former. I wanted nothing more that Hally to make it at Hull, still hope he does (!) but just cannot see it anymore.

It must be all that red and white blood coursing through him, weakening him to the core of his very existence

bet he will

The dream team is picked by a gaggle of pi$$ed up journos who play an RL version of pin the tail on the donkey by sticking pins in lists of players names whilst blindfolded.

Only fans of small clubs with large inferiority complexes actually believe it means anything

Quote ="Jake the Peg"The dream team is picked by a gaggle of pi$$ed up journos who play an RL version of pin the tail on the donkey by sticking pins in lists of players names whilst blindfolded. Only fans of small clubs with large inferiority complexes actually believe it means anything'" viewtopic.php?f=34&t=461056

Quote ="Jake the Peg"The dream team is picked by a gaggle of pi$$ed up journos who play an RL version of pin the tail on the donkey by sticking pins in lists of players names whilst blindfolded. Only fans of small clubs with large inferiority complexes actually believe it means anything'" viewtopic.php?f=34&t=461056

They're just wondering where the pins will go

As for MOS. It goes to the player who can get up after being hit by an iron bar