For what its worth miller has potential to be a a good player,gale nothing more than average at best.

I wouldn't say he was poor but I agree about the replacement bit. Think its irrelavent now anyway.

I can't believe I'm saying this but I agree with you (first time for everything I suppose). Although some pundits and so called experts see him as possibly developing into the next England half.

Can't see myself.

I don't think that Gale will be a replacement for Miller. Yes we know Shaul is a great promise for the future, but Rankin has played his best stuff at FB.

I think it may be a case of Rankin at FB Gale/Miller and Horney in the halves, Shaul maybe out on dual reg to get him week to week games and get a few more bits added to his game.

Carvell would add a bite to an already large pack, with Feka, Paea, Bowden, Green and Watts when return, Mason...not sure about

I seem to have mentioned earlier how average Gale was and you threw your dummy out the pram, all of a sudden, it's a change of opinion.

Which experts and pundits have said that?

Most odd.



....So Gale is offered a better deal by Bulls 2014 which might last for a month.
Are they even allowed to change contracts when the club is still "open to offers"?

I hope we don't sign Gale and stick with Miller.

Gale isn't the player to get us challenging the top 4.

Radders

"Carvell deal is complicated with many issues"

On Gale "we can't sign everyone we have a salary cap"

James Smailes ‏@James_Smailes 4s
BREAKING: Just bumped into an old face at Hull's training ground. Garreth Carvell is here today doing some fitness testing

lol and that was straight after Smailes quoting Radders from the press conference

Mason not coming though

James Smailes ‏@James_Smailes ·5m
Word down at Hull is with Carvell coming in there won't be any more additions to pack. So that's killed the Keith Mason rumour dead.

If someone has something to say without it being a blatant attempt to troll then I'll quite happily have a conversation but that is all you do. I didn't disagree at your previous comment either.

I've read comments about him in League express or weekly when we were linked to him a few months ago also seen the on report series on the superleague website true the guy singin his praises is an agent not sure if its his agent though.

Good: Trust in the Youth

Maybe that's the assurances my mate alluded too.

beginning to think if we sign carvell,it wont be in time for him to play Friday.

Smailes doesn't know whether he is coming or going

If Bulls decide to be awkward with transferring his registration that could well be the case.

So overall looking like 1 from 3. Carvs is a no brainer but personally would have liked to have seen Gale come. Mason was the stange one but would have been happy on a 3 month pay as you play basis until Watts / Green are fit.

It's starting to look that way isn't it. I honestly thought it would be done today and announced at todays press conference.

I would take every that's being said at the moment, even in press conferences with a pinch of salt.

Couldn`t agree more, given that Radders said the Carvell deal was compicated in his press conference and then 20mins later James Smailes bumped into Carvell at the FC trainnig ground says it all to me, plenty things going on at the moment and until things are announced offcially rumours will be spreading like wildfire

I do make sense sometimes,miller could be anything a dud or a good player,gale nearly 26 and not exactly pulled up any trees has he.Stick with youngsters with potential.

I reckon even if it's done on Wednesday he'd play Friday.

I agree. Not poor, but not better than Miller IMO. I personally think we need to see how Miller can now fit in with the first team and not the academy side.

Where on earth was the trolling? If you sign Gale you have 4 first choice half backs fighting for two spots. Some players are not going to be happy.

Ross from the T & A with an update of sorts:
So he's training with FC but still a registered Bulls player. This could get messy.

He wasnt training with the squad, he had a fitness test and met the squad