In attack JT can be awesome with his quick feet and being fairly agile for a forward, although in defence the majority of the time he can be a liability. Often goes in looking for a big hit which rarely comes off or finds himself flat footed and then attempting to shirt grab. Get this out of him and he could be twice th player he is now.

As a whole, three renewals are very good news and keeps a close knit group together.

Pleased for all there, Washy and Talanoa really deserve their deals, as well documented not convinced by Thompson, his performance haven't been great the last two seasons and I hope we don't regret this move in a tight cap. Got to have faith in Radford and his recruitment and I hope he proves me wrong.

We also have a French under 23 players on trial, think he will play in the reserves on Saturday

You have already been proved wrong , with him getting a 2 year deal . Happy with all resignings

You make it sound harsh, but I agree, been a quality signing but, need a quality signing next year, who will probably fill a quota spot

Of course I haven't unless you are telling me all of Radfords signings have been the right decision.

Just because a player gets a new deal it doesn't make int the right decision, it depends on how he does or who else we recruit.

To be honest dave, the way you talk as if your on the coaching staff makes my pixxxxsssss boil, you have been proved wrong , you constantly under rate thompsons performances , your opinion , fine, but fans and obviousky the coaching staff disagree , hence him getting a 2 year deal, deservedly so. So yes I think you are proven wrong, Thompson doesnt need to prove anything to you, hes got a new 2 year deal on the back of his performances . Proven wrong dave , just accept it

It only seems in your head Dave that it's not the right decision. Maybe you could apply for Motu's job to ensure all signings or resignings meet your approval.

People see different things in different players, I'm no Sneyd fan, but to each their own.

Radford obviously sees something in Thommo he likes.

Personally I'm happy with all the resignings.
It's all about value for money and squad balance.

Just beat me too it.

It makes your p&&is boil

what a clown you are, if that's the kind of thing that makes you angry then a feel sorry for you, it's a fans forum FFS.

If I make you that angry with my posts I suggest you press the ignore button.

You rate Thompson I don't, some fans do, some fans don't, Radford does, but like I've said as good a coach as he is, let's not pretend he is perfect and makes all the right decision.

His performances have been overall average the last two years and IMO has to prove he is worth that deal. If he plays well like he did against Wigan consistently I'll give him the credit he deserves.

Talk about double standards, you have a go at me for talking about Thompson then go on about Sneyd, maybe it's you that should apply for Motus job.

So are we not allowed a opinion on players as fans, do we have to be coaching experts if so it will be pretty boring on here.

Haha im the clown, im not the one who thinks im on the coaching staff and as inside knowledge. Yes dave your a fan , not part of the hull fc coaching staff. You suggesting Thompson doesnt deserve his extension , is disrespectful, and wrong and as proven you wrong and will prove you wronger

in the future no doubt . Of course Radford doesnt make all the correct decisions, I wanted him gone, but accept I was wrong. Unlike yourself

Hakim Miloudi is the best player in the French league and easily good enough to play in Super League, the issue is that his discipline has been terrible throughout his career, he's been fired or suspended by every club he's been at which is a decent number already given that he's only 23. If he can find a club that can control him and keep his head on straight he will be a star.

And I would ignore you , but considering you make probably 80% of the posts on here, would make it pretty confusing. You wish id ignore , because you know I see yiu for the fraud you are ha

Hardly gone on about Sneyd have I Dave?

I was merely highlighting the fact I'm not a Sneyd fan but don't feel the need to criticize him as regularly as you do Thompson nor do. I question the coaches signings again as you do.

If you cannot respond to criticism well, which you have demonstrated in your last 2 replies that you clearly can't, then maybe it's you that should think twice before posting, remember it's a forum Dave.

I do not come on here looking to fall out but if your going to post your opinions at least have the respect of other people's opinions even when they don't agree with you.

No need to name call or accuse people of double standards.

Anyway let's see how well your application goes.

I hope I'm wrong, I only want whats best for Hull FC, if I'm right it doesn't help us does it. But he need to be more consistent, stronger in defence and attack.

I've been wrong before and will be wrong again, I wanted Radford out at times as well, but was wrong.

Not sure why just having an opinion makes you think I think I'm on the coaching staff, I certainly don't, just like you having an opinion the likes of Thompson.

Let's hope I'm wronger!!!!

I see you are poor at Maths as well.

You do want you need to do, I just want you getting really angry at my posts, can't be good for your health.

So it's a forum but you can't critise players or the coaches decisions?

I respect people's opinion and if you and Tinkerman rate Thompson fair enough, I don't.

If we can't challenge people's opinions then this forum is pointless..

Give up dave , 1 nil Tinkerman

and thats been generous

Why pick a fight you've already lost?

For me its not that you dont rate thompson or his potential. Its your lack of respect for accepting hes earned a new 2 year deal

Thanks, had a quick look and he is a centre, good to see us looking for players in a few places, maybe worth a risk.

Standee backing you up now

I leave it there.

I hope I'm wronger and he gets MOTM on Sunday.

??

So, had we not given Thompson an extension, who should we go for?