Good post.

You predicted that Miller and Rankin would play more games together than Horne and an other. That was the definition of ridiculous. Also claiming that 'the thread finished here' as you did earlier could possibly be deemed even more ridiculous than that.

Of course I'll predict they will, they're younger and don't have diabetes to effect recovery. I don't see Radford stating he'll only get 15 games out of Miller or Rankin.

I'd prefer us to have a consistent halfback partnership [icapable[/i of playing 27 games. Horne would be a brilliant back up.

So you'd have Horne on the sidelines waiting until Miller or Rankin got injured even if Horne had showed far better form than either/both of the other two ?

Radders has said in the press if he gets 15 games our of Horne he will be happy so this to me says they've got to stay in form & compete for a shirt that doesn't mean he will play him for 15 then stop or pick & choose his games so he gets 15, just with wear & tear on the older guys in the squad taking longer to get over, radders sees it as a bonus for Horne/FC to play regular.

I'd give them first crack, yes. And I'd only change it for injury. I just see consistency as paramount over anything else, and to be fair it's the only position I would make that sacrifice.
Id rather have a consistent partnership for 27 games than a marginally better one for half a season. In the long run I think that will serve us better.

Fair enough. For me it's the most important position in the team to have form players playing.

You have already said that your not a fan of Rankin and more importantly don't even see him as a half back yet you would only drop him if injured and keep a fit and probably our most consistent player in the first half of last season(horne)on the bench regardless of form,bewildering.

We've been waiting for ages for decent h.backs and now imo we have got 3 so let's just enjoy the fact of the competition for places

COYH

I seem to recall last year having Seymour , Holdsworth and Horne available and being very surprised that Seymour and Holdsworth barely got 15 minutes together in pre season games. I think if you bring players in on long , expensive contracts , especially in pivotal positions , then you've already made a decision that these players are "first choice" and it has to then make sense to make the roles theirs to lose and give them time together to create an understanding with each other and the rest of the team. At least then you know whether the decision to bring them in was right or wrong , ie potentially just poor recruitment , as opposed to it being lack of game time , not gelling , losing confidence , not getting a platform from the pack etc etc.

What if they're consistently shiit?

They Don't play!!

Unless all three are playing shiit then i'd go with Miller and Rankin to build a partnership for the long term and if they keep playing shiit get rid asap..

They won't be.

Think the season will end with Rankin & Miller in the halves but fully exoecting Horne to start in the opener against Catalan. As you say 3 decent half backs is the best position we have had for some time (and although not my choice Heramaia also as an option)

I expect, Miller to have gone home, before the season ends.

Is that just a feeling? Or have you heard something?

I've got a feeling McDonnell won't see the year out.

I also don't see Miller being here at the end of the season. I think he'll be dropped and through either a club decision or his own he'll be on his way. Hope I'm wrong cos that would mean all is rosy, just haven't seen anything from him last season to suggest he will cut it. Cue, he was great against Widnes for 90 seconds replies.....

That would be a strange decision if it was purely down to on field performances between the two players.

Millers played about 50mins in pre-season 20 of which he played pretty well dragging a young side off of the deck against Donny for the draw. Yet some already have his bags packed resigned to the scrap heap at 22.
FFS.

This is FC mate, it happens every year for one of our players.

Jeez, you don't help yourself, EHFCF, do you?

Wonderful performance against Barrel Burns. Hope he stays long enough for a round 2.

Don't get it?

He was east hull fc fan before you started posting on here so changed his user name

Ahh I'm with you now..lol trying to watch united & thought what have I done now!