id say it was sarcasm

I'd like to see Brough back as long as we sign a top class partner for him in the half back role. All great sides have 2 great half backs.

His long kicking game is top drawer and we are in desperate need of that as well as his organising skills

Broughy would love to come back to play in Hull. We would need a class stand off if this was to happen though and Horne would slot into Fullback/Centre.

Says in Daily Express today Huddersfield have tabled a £100k offer for Broughy.

I can imagine what some fans would be like if we sign Brough for 100k when we wouldn't pay that for Dobson.

Same as me, would be a great signing in the short term, but long term think we need to be looking at better... unless we sign Brough move Horne to Fullback and sign a top NRL no 6.

I am not so sure we will get a SH next season. We may end up going for a SO from overseas and playing Horne alongside him.

On Brough I always liked him at Hull, he can be hit and miss and does have his faults but he is better than Thorman and is a genuine no.7.

Brough game seems to have improved in the last two years, Agar also had him at York and was heavily involved in bringing him to Hull (I Think).

I like you would love to see a top class 7 been signed but have doubts that it will happen, so maybe this wouldn't be a bad thing.

If he signs we need to send big on a top FB or SO.

Brough is what ween right now......but wont happen, Kath will see to that! As she orchestrated his departure.....not sharpe as many believe.

We let Brough go because we had one of the best young half-back pairings around in Richard Horne and Paul Cooke (sorry but its true)

We also had a freak of a hooker who played 80 mins every game and tackled like a machine.

Brough was surplus to requirements at the time. He has certainly improved since the time he stuck at cas in NL1 because he couldn't get a SL contract.

If Hudds have offered 100k for Brough would this suggest that they have cooled on the Finch prospect, and what happens to Robinson?
If we were to go for Brough at 100k it should be in our range as we have saved the 70k on Reardon.
I'd take him if there wasn't anybody better available, but I'd go 'all in' for a top class Oz for next year, hopefully we are in with a shout on Finch.

Finch wont be signing for any club in this country, he signed for Melbourne Storm and made his debut this weekend against New Zealand Warriors.

Signed, but only til the end of the season

Think Reardon was £50k?

Not sure how much we may have saved on Byrne or how much cap space that freed up.

Broughy on his way to Shudds and Robinson could well be on his way to the kc, watch this space

I hope not but it wouldnt suprise me.

While not wanting to dismiss the Brough stuff out of hand...

Why would he want to leave Wakey? Why would Wakey let him go? He's key to their recent successes and they don't have a replacement of similar quality.

Well i hope he can play football!!

Wash your mouth out son

i dont think robinson is the ideal answer,
but never the less i wouldnt mind him at hull

I really hope we dont sign Robinson and I hope we wouldnt be interested in Brough either. Both are better than Thorman (I never thought Robinson was until I saw Thorman play for us) but we need a top 7, which Brough and Robinson are not. Signing players in this position who either arent good enough or injury prone is what has been our problem since Tony Smith retired through injury and just because both are better than what we have currently it doesnt mean we still wouldnt have a problem at halfback

Hull should have signed Dobson when they had the chance

We need an organiser not a running 7!!

Mate, this kid does it all. £100k per season???

Worth every penny

Should have kept James Webster then. Could have signed a lot worse, in fact you did.