Thats my point exactly its a sink or swim scenario for me, you put Tuffour or Lynne in and they either come out the other side a better player or you'll have your confidence shot to pieces.
Surly you have to give them a shot at some point

From what i have seen Lyne looks the better of the two but with both down as Wingers i would definately like to see one of them given a outing against Salford.

The reason Hall isnt a regular is because those closer to him within the playing / coaching staff than anyone on here simply dont think he is good enough to be a regular, he fills gaps when needed simple as that!
His defence is at best awful hence why ALL teams target him over and over when running with the ball.
his likeness to Matt tiss earlier in this thread was laughable at best IMO
Whiting gets a run every week based on merit, he is a far more complete player than Hall and brings more to the table that Hall does...
Hall has a few blasts with ball in hand admitted but not enough to even put him in the top 10 centres in my opinion...

Happy to let go to be honest or keep as a infill when needed . international class erm no not while my bits hand south

Good job you're not in charge then isn't it.

shame

not in charge correct but those who ARE in charge see him as in fill flesh as well hence his appearances thus far!!

if he was this super duper centre some think he is then he would be first on the fag packet at centre wouldnt he , however he is not!!

i second that,why dont you have a lye down and take another valium,,No one will deny or argue whiting has been playing very well over the last few games but there is no way he would score more trys as centre as craig hall would,,if he is so bad then hull wouldnt play him period and would of off loaded him last season but did'nt what does that tell you,,probably nothing!!!

correct
However there is also defence involved in a match of which Whiting is leagues ahead of Hall !!!

Correct...However there is no way he would let in as many tries as Hall would



Stop your opposition scoring tries and you cannot lose a game

I'd try and keep them both.

Are you sure?

his defence as much improved this season,The whole teams defence is very questionable at best for some games,,if you don't like him as a player then fais enough you made your point enough and move on or instaed why don't you get behind the WHOLE team no matter who they are anybody would think we are doing sh*t but you can't allways please some people and just are moaning sods

Theoretically yes...unless Hame gives a penalty away and they take the 2

It is....personally I thought our defence was pants in the 2 games we have lost, in most games our defence is light years ahead of what it has been for 2 seasons..

my thoughts exactly but people like him just and still single out the one person when its the team as a whole are to blame thats why they call it a TEAM

*cough* Drop goal *cough*

no you can't, if we have a poor season agar could lose his job.

If he bloods youngsters or rests players and we lose people will call for his head.

Good spot forgot about that one



So basically my theory has been blown to pieces



OK if we defend we can stop tries going in which is a massive asset towards not losing a game, unless there is a penalty or drop goal

Based upon the showing thus far this season he isnt going to loose his job and why should he??
He said with his team he would build for the future and thats exactly what he is doing

so if he rests a few players, plays a few youngsters, and we lose on sat the against hkr, wire and Leeds twice (who are more than capable of beating us) no one will call for his head?

your missing my point young fella, why would he rest anyone who isnt injured?? remember the Crusaders match ??? no game is a defined win

Er ok

er definate, thats why this season so far he has rested no one who isnt injured!! FACT

have you read the thread?

oh yes indeed