I agree we have a hate/hate relationship. Loaning players to your enemy is a non starter !
What a load of TOSH !!

Maybe we would want to show that we are bigger than that. At the end of the day we are a business, and if it helps develop one of our assets by loaning him to rovers and it saves us some cash because they pay for his wages and development, and then they send is him back a better player why would we not loan a player to them?

I dont understand the talk of cutting our noses off to spite our faces, even with the history between the clubs it wouldnt make sense.

you better not find out what else we've loaned them then mate

Their Ground ?

Justine ?

Or is it CASH !!!!!

It depends if loaning the player makes a big difference to their performances it could be a case where we are battling with them at the end of the season an one of our players has helped them gain an extra couple of points. Cant see who they would want apart from Hodgson? unless they have a problem with a player(injury) and they dont want to people to know about it until they have cover?

Didnt read the thread properly, thought we were talking hypothetically?

Doubt we will be bottom 3 this season to be battling with them!

I aint read the thread either so we might be



Talking Hypothetically that is. And your right I can see your second point

Warriors deny Witt is on the outer
2/26/2009 4:04 PM

Warriors director of football John Hart says although Michael Witt is not the first choice standoff, doesn't mean he won't play


Warriors director of football John Hart has refuted standoff Michael Witt's claims he is on the outer with the club.


Witt says he has been told by coach Ivan Cleary he is basically surplus to requirements and will start the season with the Auckland Vulcans.


But Hart says that is not to say Witt will never play first grade for the Warriors. He says Witt has been told he is not first choice and if he wants to leave they will consider it.


Witt says he was told last year he could negotiate with other clubs but following the NRL finals, but when a new offer surfaced from Hull in the UK, the Warriors decided they wanted to keep him.


Hart says they never knew anything about the apparent contract offer.

Thorman and Witt in the halves, R Horne to full back. Theres the solution!

Can you just link the article please and not C&P it, thanks.

I got told last December we had tried to sign Witt but the Warriors decided to keep him.

www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/ar ... d=10558866, its there

www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/ar ... d=10558866, its there

Also here www.theaustralian.news.com.au/st ... 22,00.html

Also here www.theaustralian.news.com.au/st ... 22,00.html

hhhmmm we will still want him a year later?

i cant see it happening,
with thorman and horne,
i do not expect agar to try and sign a half back,
and also dependant on crocker

If crocker doesnt come, I think he will be a good signing. I still think we need cover in the halves and it would finish the squad of nicely

could witt be on his way over now byrne is out for the season?

If Witt is much better than Horne and/or Thorman and we have the chance to do it, then we really should.

witt isn't better than horne, thorman maybe.

lee smith or chris ashton?

Been told we are intrested in Lee Smith from a (alleged in the know

) Leeds fan , I originally laughed it off but then was told he is out of contract at end of season / and a couple people since have mentioned we are intrested

But then again if some of the posts on this site from people who claim to be in the know is anything to go by its probally just a load of c**p

really? source

smith would be a very addition to the squad, i'd be very happy if he was our fb next season.

Thaiday can be removed from the rumour list

[urlhttp://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,25114063-23214,00.html[/url

Can't see it tbh, Smith has been linked with Union and only the lure of big money would take him away from Leeds, I very much doubt he would leave Leeds for another SL club as he is a Leeds lad.

Depends whether he feels guaranteed first team football at Leeds.
Probably a load of tosh anyway. Most of our signings never make to the rumour stage, they just appear out of the blue.

He is. If/When Webb returns then Smith will play centre.