Not just at fc you look at brisbane and queensland clips looks moody git then. I think berro's class just playing in a average team and not many on his wavelength

it goes for all teams some you get some you don't

Maybe that's what's wrong with Agar?? Maybe the players aren't on his wavelength!

so why comment on ours

without reading through 10 pages of complete rubbish know doubt, my opinion is good luck to the lad he was 4th choice at hull for the hooker position (granted 3rd choice when lee is gone) but he can hopefully get a shot at rovers with being 2nd fiddle the fisher.
Imo from what i've seen of him (1st team and a handful of reserve games) he's done nothing to suggest that he could cut it at sl level, (been dominated in the 1st team games he's featured in) you can take all the plaudits in u21's but it doesn't neccesary mean that you will make the step up. i felt he'll be another matty dale type player who we'll hang onto for to long with out him ever making the step up, there are plenty of other positions in our team we could do with developing youngsters for that aren't overly covered i.e halfback,fullback.

Time will tell i suppose but good look to the lad.

Good post mate

i remeber other players like Danny Hill, Ian Bell, Andy Last, both the young Thackarys and many, all able to rip it up in the reserves

lets be honest how many players have we developed over the years that have gone on to bigger things and the others that have drifted into the background.
We seem to keep players for far to long imo instead of admitting they won't make it and take the risk of releasing them and some members of the current squad can be mentioned with those comments.

Thankyou Hull FC !

It seems that now Hodgson has signed for rovers he has gone from being the next big thing to nothing special.

Having read through 11 pages of this thread it seems that you're happy, we're happy, everyone's happy

We have done. Once he's developed into a 'world class' hooker we'll have him back.

You can't blame the lad for taking the best deal on offer.

But would Rovers have offered him the deal if he played for anyone other than Hull

No, most certainly not. That's the only reason we signed him, you know.

We're hoping to snatch Thorman next. That'll really teach you...

you're welcome, we'll even pay 50% of his salary.

Maybe not the only reason but I'm sure it was one of them.

Seriously though, good luck to the lad.

People go on here about having too many average utitlity players and as soon as Agar gets rid of one people moan.

With the players that Agar has brought in sacrifices have to be made, and if we are going to lose a player then hooker must be one of the few positions that we can afford to lose.

Josh is a decent player and if he is played at hooker he can make a decent impact in SL (which was never going to happen at Hull with the players we have).

I think this is a good move for Hull, Rovers and Josh.

Good luck to him.

i commented on yours because you was making out it was only us that was linked to players but never signed them

We let Hodgson go, and keep Whiting, pathetic.

Sorry Martin but that is just crap....think there is only you on here who doest rate Whiting......Hodgson wont dislodge Berro or Houghton,yet Whiting offers us much more along the back line.....2 squad players but 1 offers so much more to the other.

The club obviously don't rate Whiting that highly, 1 year deal. There are plenty of supporters that don't frequent these forums that see Whitings failings, remember, RLFans is not representative of all FC fans, just a small minority.

TBF Whiting will always be just a squad player, but Hodgson has a massive future ahead of him as a hooker. You need to look at the bigger picture.

Yup, and Berrigan goes relatively soon.

Not entirely convinced of that from what I've seen. There again, I don't wear red & white tinted glasses.

Berro has another year to do and then an option year which is on the club! Speak to him or listen to him on the Radio and he wants to stay as long as his body will hold out! Houghton wants to stay at the club, other wise he would have gone to the dobbins when they tapped him up, twice, So you think that with sparce cover in the backs and particulaly at half back we should keep 3 hookers?

respect your view but on this occassion don't agree with it!

There's a surprise.





The rest of your post is just the usual tribal, chest beating nonsense