Just looking at the squads from last night

Wigan only one missing from 1-13 (8. Lauaki)
Hull missing six, almost half the team (2,3,6,7,11 & 12) and I would guess those six are over 50% of our cap

Yet we gave Wigan a game, well done lads. With players coming back in over the next few weeks we need to remember nothing is won in Super League until 5th October...

Thing is mate some teams seem to regularly get the touch whilst others have to regularly settle for the go.

We lost every 50/50 call last night . Could be wrong but did the ref give 1 forward pass in the game ?

Dont really agree with the players missing bit - Crookes is fit so is being kept out by Lineham. I think if Arundel was fit, Crooks would still be in before him. Seymour was dropped for Horne prior to his illness. So really we were only missing Holdsworth, Ellis and Tickle. Saying that, if we had them 3 i think we would have won. Bit more composure and organisation would have done it

Superb effort last night, best display of the season by a distance. At 0-12 and 10-24 I thought we may have caved in mentally but we never and fought back well.

Refereeing was shocking, the decision to penalise Shannon was poor and their first try was forward. Also not sure on the Charnley try. Worst decision for me was the penlty for laying on to make it 20-26, it was the only penality he gave all night for laying on, disgraceful. Wigan slowed the ptb down all night and Lockers was never onside all match.

For me it was the night Crooks came of age. Created tries and made a few line breaks, should be the making of him and along with Lineham it looks a great partnership which will only be strengthened further when Ellis is out there with them.

Also though Pitts had his best game this season, his ability to spin and use footwork to get away from tacklers was excellent. Horne continued his impressive form too.

Last night reminded me just why I love the mighty FC. What a performance against 14 men. Lets kick on from here.

I thought it was a fine match with both teams playing slightly a different style of rugby.

In my opinion the match was somewhat spoilt for me by Richard Silverwood. He must know the rules but clearly for whatever reason either does not implement or is selective when similar offences occur, examples being forward passes, obsruction @ 'play the ball' & 'lying on'. Regarding certain tries being awarded that has been covered by others.

I am not hopeful that Peter Gentle will get anywhere with Steve Ganson but he must make his views known. ard

Had typing problen please disregard the last few letters should have deleted them.

Last night was a classic case of a ref being intimidated by a top of the table side.
Wigan are masters at sailing close to the wind within the laws of the game.Silverwood was scared stiff of giving a call in our favour late in the game.
Wigan a great side , they are good enough without help from the officials. The constant wingeing from Green and Tompkins was their attempt to control Silverwood and he fell for it.Maybe the game was too fast for him?
As for the touchjudges, what do they do ? Wigan were constantly offside in the defensive line . Also how many forward passes went unseen ?

Has Goulding managed to get back onside yet?

The penalty against McDonnell was 100% correct as he made no attempt to clear the ruck and was wandering around like some surrendering Italian.

It was a great advert for our game last night. Its a shame it wasn't a tv game. At times it felt like I was watching a wrestling match. We didn't get the 50/50 decisions. I rather have a game refereed like it was than a game with more penalties. Nearly 50 points scored. Got to give Wigan some credit for there lines they ran and there quickness of their passing.

No reason why you can't get right in the mix for the two trophies when you get the big guns back. I thought you were very good last night and we were quite fortunate in some respects.

Bit rough having practically all your new players out - I knew Ellis and Holdsworth were missing but I don't think Arundel and Galea were there either were they?

Any idea when those four will be back?

Ellis and Holdsworth will probably be back next week when we take on London but i aint quite sure on Galea and Arundel.

If galea was back next week I wouldn't pick him, prefer westy, whiting, Pitts and Ellis to him.

These along with green and Hadley are the future, galea should be used if we are struggling.

He seemed to slow the play down and we look better without him.

Tickle was probably our biggest miss last night, for his goal-kicking.

Think Holdsworth would have kicked a couple of the missed kicks as well as giving Horney some help. Thought Heremia was well bottled up.

I cannot see how he can get back in .

Looked to me like Green was carrying a knock last night, but Gentle thought no new injuries?

I thought he was bought as back up anyway, so if Westy Ellis and Ticks are fit he wouldn't be in

I wouldn't be surprised to see him take over from Hay.

Silver wood on twitter has confirmed that after review, Charnley got the ball down. Also only forward pass he missed was Horne to Crooks for his break in 2nd half

Regarding touch judges, I always wonder if they do actually say something but the referee just chooses to ignore it/overrule it. For all we know, every single penalty/knock on a referee gives could be down to a call in the ear from a touch judge. If that's the case then refereeing is a job I could even do!!

Looked a bit miffed at not playing. Watched the game from the West Stand with Big Willie.

Which one?